Narrator/Host

This is only the second time he had ever been here, and he could still remember where he parked.

It was worth taking him back out there and having him tell it from his own, the viewpoint of the guy that was there the night this happened.

Did he give an indication of why it is that he did what he did, what Alden did?

The only explanation that I'm aware of is that Wymonk, being another Marine, asked him for help, and he agreed.

You're a Marine.

Would you do that?

Absolutely not.

After he confessed, Kyle Alden was charged, and he ultimately pleaded guilty.

Kyle Alden was sentenced to approximately five years in prison.

And at a hearing for John Weimunk, Holly's brother Beau sees the man he once called a friend now accused of killing his sister.

But we stood up when Weimunk came in and he didn't even look.

He didn't turn around.

Ultimately, in 2010, John Weimunk pled guilty to first-degree murder.

John Weimunk is sentenced to life in prison for arson, conspiracy to commit arson, and Holly's murder.

The district attorney called me and he said, I have Weimark here.

His parents have convinced him to take a plea of life without parole.

I said, you just take the plea and send him to prison.

So that's what they did.

Did you hope there was a death penalty?

I personally wanted it, yeah.