Natalie Morales

Yeah. What is so incredible, I mean, this was a cold case for more than two decades. And when it came to, they were able to solve the crime and crack the case in a little less than three months, right? They were working at a fast and furious pace, though.

So that's a lot of hours. And then it turns out that Shara hits pay dirt with... the DNA and she is able to build out that family tree and get it to a point where she pared it down to two brothers, Michael and Clayton Foreman. And it turns out they went to the same high school as Catherine Edwards. So what did they find when they looked into Clayton and how did that eliminate Michael?

So that's a lot of hours. And then it turns out that Shara hits pay dirt with... the DNA and she is able to build out that family tree and get it to a point where she pared it down to two brothers, Michael and Clayton Foreman. And it turns out they went to the same high school as Catherine Edwards. So what did they find when they looked into Clayton and how did that eliminate Michael?

So that's a lot of hours. And then it turns out that Shara hits pay dirt with... the DNA and she is able to build out that family tree and get it to a point where she pared it down to two brothers, Michael and Clayton Foreman. And it turns out they went to the same high school as Catherine Edwards. So what did they find when they looked into Clayton and how did that eliminate Michael?

Yeah. We saw the remarkable police interrogation. I mean, that was sort of a masterpiece in police work and so fascinating to see how they sort of wove through the interrogation and then kind of cornered Clayton Foreman. So Ranger Bess and Detective Llewellyn, they essentially tag-teamed the whole thing. But then comes the real clincher of the moment there, right, Mary?

Yeah. We saw the remarkable police interrogation. I mean, that was sort of a masterpiece in police work and so fascinating to see how they sort of wove through the interrogation and then kind of cornered Clayton Foreman. So Ranger Bess and Detective Llewellyn, they essentially tag-teamed the whole thing. But then comes the real clincher of the moment there, right, Mary?

Yeah. We saw the remarkable police interrogation. I mean, that was sort of a masterpiece in police work and so fascinating to see how they sort of wove through the interrogation and then kind of cornered Clayton Foreman. So Ranger Bess and Detective Llewellyn, they essentially tag-teamed the whole thing. But then comes the real clincher of the moment there, right, Mary?

It's a moment, he said, he was doing that for her as if he was able to physically take the handcuffs off of her when she was murdered and put them back on the guy who was responsible for killing her. I mean, it was a huge deal and definitely for them a moment where I think they felt, you know, finally job done.

It's a moment, he said, he was doing that for her as if he was able to physically take the handcuffs off of her when she was murdered and put them back on the guy who was responsible for killing her. I mean, it was a huge deal and definitely for them a moment where I think they felt, you know, finally job done.

It's a moment, he said, he was doing that for her as if he was able to physically take the handcuffs off of her when she was murdered and put them back on the guy who was responsible for killing her. I mean, it was a huge deal and definitely for them a moment where I think they felt, you know, finally job done.

Welcome back. And now to the big twist in this case. We interviewed Catherine's childhood friend, Diana Coe, who had once been married to Clayton Foreman. Clayton Foreman was Catherine's killer. Jen, I think listeners would be really surprised to know. I mean, you were the booking producer. You helped get us all these great people and characters. But Diana took a long time.

Welcome back. And now to the big twist in this case. We interviewed Catherine's childhood friend, Diana Coe, who had once been married to Clayton Foreman. Clayton Foreman was Catherine's killer. Jen, I think listeners would be really surprised to know. I mean, you were the booking producer. You helped get us all these great people and characters. But Diana took a long time.

Welcome back. And now to the big twist in this case. We interviewed Catherine's childhood friend, Diana Coe, who had once been married to Clayton Foreman. Clayton Foreman was Catherine's killer. Jen, I think listeners would be really surprised to know. I mean, you were the booking producer. You helped get us all these great people and characters. But Diana took a long time.

She only agreed to do this interview with us just days before the broadcast aired. How difficult was it to convince her to do it.

She only agreed to do this interview with us just days before the broadcast aired. How difficult was it to convince her to do it.

She only agreed to do this interview with us just days before the broadcast aired. How difficult was it to convince her to do it.

Well, and I think she recognizes and she realizes that If there are other victims of his out there, you know, she was doing this for them as well. She wants them to be able to have a voice and to be able to come forward. And she feels by telling her story, perhaps they will come forward too. Yeah, I think that was very important to her and one of the deciding factors. But she did say...

Well, and I think she recognizes and she realizes that If there are other victims of his out there, you know, she was doing this for them as well. She wants them to be able to have a voice and to be able to come forward. And she feels by telling her story, perhaps they will come forward too. Yeah, I think that was very important to her and one of the deciding factors. But she did say...

Well, and I think she recognizes and she realizes that If there are other victims of his out there, you know, she was doing this for them as well. She wants them to be able to have a voice and to be able to come forward. And she feels by telling her story, perhaps they will come forward too. Yeah, I think that was very important to her and one of the deciding factors. But she did say...

she did feel some guilt for being the connection between Clayton and her friends, Catherine and Allison, because they were the bridesmaids at their wedding. She felt like perhaps she introduced Catherine and Allison into his orbit. So there's that heartbreaking moment when Diana said, I think if he wouldn't have married me, she'd still be alive. I mean, that just gutted me when she said that.