Nathan Lee

I was getting information from all agencies and giving the updates.

I was 100% confident we'd find her.

I thought she was somewhere.

He must have just dropped her off in the woods somewhere or, you know, she's wandering on the side of a road and they would find her.

With the search going on, questions are swirling around Michael King.

To his parents, the accusations are unbelievable.

This is the first time King's posed for a mugshot in Florida.

The unemployed plumber doesn't have a criminal record here.

Police visit King's ex-girlfriend, who tells them she's equally stunned.

No.

King has an 11-year-old son whom he'd been raising on his own.

At the time, that boy was living with relatives in another state.

We learned that Michael King was going through foreclosure at the time and had broken up with his girlfriend.

It seemed like a person that was down on his luck.

Police turn to King's cousin to try to get some answers.

But the story he's telling now doesn't match what his daughter Sabrina says he told her.

Faced with this contradictory account, investigators bring Muxlow in for a polygraph exam.

No.

No.

Finally, Muxlow admits to what he saw.