Menu
Sign In Search Podcasts Libraries Charts People & Topics Add Podcast API Blog Pricing

Nina Totenberg

๐Ÿ‘ค Speaker
See mentions of this person in podcasts
581 total appearances

Appearances Over Time

Podcast Appearances

The NPR Politics Podcast
SCOTUS hears birthright citizenship arguments

Well, I have to tell you in truth that sitting in the press section, I don't think any of us except maybe one or two people on the far end could see the president at all.

The NPR Politics Podcast
SCOTUS hears birthright citizenship arguments

And the White House had imposed a new restriction on how we cover the court, which is they told us to sit down before the court started, the proceeding started.

The NPR Politics Podcast
SCOTUS hears birthright citizenship arguments

The guards told us to sit down.

The NPR Politics Podcast
SCOTUS hears birthright citizenship arguments

And I very clearly said, you know, this is our job is to look and see what's going on in this courtroom.

The NPR Politics Podcast
SCOTUS hears birthright citizenship arguments

at least before the proceedings began.

The NPR Politics Podcast
SCOTUS hears birthright citizenship arguments

And they said, well, I'm sorry, this isn't our decision.

The NPR Politics Podcast
SCOTUS hears birthright citizenship arguments

This is a new rule that the White House imposed on us.

The NPR Politics Podcast
SCOTUS hears birthright citizenship arguments

So I didn't see anything of the precedent.

The NPR Politics Podcast
SCOTUS hears birthright citizenship arguments

But part of that is, of course, also that I'm short.

The NPR Politics Podcast
SCOTUS hears birthright citizenship arguments

Well, what really stood out to me was that they were on their best behavior.

The NPR Politics Podcast
SCOTUS hears birthright citizenship arguments

They really didn't beat up counsel a lot.

The NPR Politics Podcast
SCOTUS hears birthright citizenship arguments

You know, what you see today as skeptical questions, which, you know, we always write this intro, this introduction to a piece that says the Supreme Court appeared skeptical today or ready to reverse or whatever.

The NPR Politics Podcast
SCOTUS hears birthright citizenship arguments

Certainly when you look at the body of two hours plus of argument,

The NPR Politics Podcast
SCOTUS hears birthright citizenship arguments

you can see where the wind is blowing if it's indicative.

The NPR Politics Podcast
SCOTUS hears birthright citizenship arguments

On the other hand, none of the justices were really... They didn't get in big fights with either counsel.

The NPR Politics Podcast
SCOTUS hears birthright citizenship arguments

And it helped also that there were only two.

The NPR Politics Podcast
SCOTUS hears birthright citizenship arguments

Sometimes we have several and it gets very complicated.

The NPR Politics Podcast
SCOTUS hears birthright citizenship arguments

But here we had...

The NPR Politics Podcast
SCOTUS hears birthright citizenship arguments

Cecilia Wong representing the ACLU and the clients of the ACLU.

The NPR Politics Podcast
SCOTUS hears birthright citizenship arguments

And then we had the government's chief advocate, John Sauer, who, by the way, was President Trump's personal lawyer before he became Solicitor General.