Rabbi Aryeh Lebowitz
π€ SpeakerAppearances Over Time
Podcast Appearances
It happens to be, the Akronim point out,
That's probably not true.
We probably hold you are Yotzei Yerchiev if you say it not loud enough for you to hear it.
But really, you're supposed to say it loud enough for yourself to hear it.
Bishop Brewer points out that when you say it loud enough for you to hear it, when you say benching out loud, at least that you're able to hear it with your own ears, it will inspire greater kavanah.
That's typically true.
And it will likely prevent you from missing the additions on Shabbos and Yom Tov that you're supposed to add in.
That's all in benching alone.
But as far as Zimon is concerned, that everyone should say quietly along with the Mavarich who's saying it out loud.
And the Ramat adds, that when you're saying it along with the guy who's leading the benching, jump ahead a little bit toward the end of the bracha, so that you can answer Amin to his bracha.
The Mishabur explains that you, the Mavarech, if the Mavarech doesn't at least say the first bracha out loud,
or loud enough for others to quietly say along with him.
Then he's not even going to say Zimun.
So the first bracha is most critical to say out loud, but really, if you're leading benching, you're supposed to say the whole thing out loud.
And hopefully people will learn the halachos and they'll know what to do with that.
Okay, question number eight.
What are the halachic and hashkafic parameters of a chumash asaruchim when hosting certain people is personally very difficult?
How does one balance working on midos with legitimate limits in one's home?
You know, basically this question seems to be that Lachlan Sokrom is really hard, so do I have to do it?
The answer is, it's probably such a great mitzvah because it is inconvenient.