Rennie

The reason why I wouldn't pick Sam Walker is because I've already got a spine of either Ponga or Walsh, Munster and Harry Grant.

And I just think that you've got enough attacking flair in that spine.

I just want a conservative seven that goes in there, kicks really well and a great defender.

Fair point.

I'm going Fogarty.

Oh, yeah.

Is he a Queenslander?

He's a Queenslander.

He's older.

He's experienced.

He took Raiders to a minor premiership.

Manly are absolutely flying.

He's going to go in there and he's just going to plug and play, kick really well, strong defender.

And the team needs to be focused around Munster and Walsh and Harry Grant if he wants it.

I just think with those three in the spine already, like it's too many players to get the ball to.

Like Sam Walker, his job at the Roosters is to create things around him.

Whereas in origin, it's probably Munster or Walsh I reckon is probably who you're going to be going to to go, let's have something happen there.

So like deserving wise, I think Sam Walker is the most deserving.

And let's say he had a spine that was like, for example, like a conservative nine and maybe a fullback like Dylan Edwards or something like that.

I'd go Sam Walker because he can be a spark.