3 Takeaways™
The Winner’s Curse: Why “Winning” Often Means You Just Lost with Nobel Laureate Richard Thaler (#288)
Certainly in my parents' generation, pensions were like Social Security.
3 Takeaways™
The Winner’s Curse: Why “Winning” Often Means You Just Lost with Nobel Laureate Richard Thaler (#288)
They just depended on how much you made.
3 Takeaways™
The Winner’s Curse: Why “Winning” Often Means You Just Lost with Nobel Laureate Richard Thaler (#288)
You had no choices to make.
3 Takeaways™
The Winner’s Curse: Why “Winning” Often Means You Just Lost with Nobel Laureate Richard Thaler (#288)
And when they were getting started, lots of people weren't even joining.
3 Takeaways™
The Winner’s Curse: Why “Winning” Often Means You Just Lost with Nobel Laureate Richard Thaler (#288)
Now, this is really dumb because at most companies, there's a match.
3 Takeaways™
The Winner’s Curse: Why “Winning” Often Means You Just Lost with Nobel Laureate Richard Thaler (#288)
So they'll match your saving dollar for dollar, even 50 cents on the dollar.
3 Takeaways™
The Winner’s Curse: Why “Winning” Often Means You Just Lost with Nobel Laureate Richard Thaler (#288)
If you turn that down, that's throwing money away.
3 Takeaways™
The Winner’s Curse: Why “Winning” Often Means You Just Lost with Nobel Laureate Richard Thaler (#288)
So how can we help?
3 Takeaways™
The Winner’s Curse: Why “Winning” Often Means You Just Lost with Nobel Laureate Richard Thaler (#288)
Well, it used to be that at almost all companies to join, you had to fill out some form and say, yes, I want to join and I want to invest my money in the following funds.
3 Takeaways™
The Winner’s Curse: Why “Winning” Often Means You Just Lost with Nobel Laureate Richard Thaler (#288)
Filling out one form isn't really that big of a deal, but it was enough of a deal that at one company, only half the workers had joined within their first year of employment, costing themselves thousands of dollars.
3 Takeaways™
The Winner’s Curse: Why “Winning” Often Means You Just Lost with Nobel Laureate Richard Thaler (#288)
What did we suggest?
3 Takeaways™
The Winner’s Curse: Why “Winning” Often Means You Just Lost with Nobel Laureate Richard Thaler (#288)
Let's change the default.
3 Takeaways™
The Winner’s Curse: Why “Winning” Often Means You Just Lost with Nobel Laureate Richard Thaler (#288)
So we'll make it that unless you fill out a form, we're going to enroll you at a certain saving rate and into a certain fund.
3 Takeaways™
The Winner’s Curse: Why “Winning” Often Means You Just Lost with Nobel Laureate Richard Thaler (#288)
One of my then colleagues, Bridget Madrian, studied a firm that made this switch and enrollment within the first year went from 50% to 90% just by making it automatic.
3 Takeaways™
The Winner’s Curse: Why “Winning” Often Means You Just Lost with Nobel Laureate Richard Thaler (#288)
That left a problem that the default saving rate was too low.
3 Takeaways™
The Winner’s Curse: Why “Winning” Often Means You Just Lost with Nobel Laureate Richard Thaler (#288)
So another one of my students, and I came up with a plan to fix that, that we called Save More Tomorrow.
3 Takeaways™
The Winner’s Curse: Why “Winning” Often Means You Just Lost with Nobel Laureate Richard Thaler (#288)
What we offered people was you can increase your saving rate next year when you get a raise.
3 Takeaways™
The Winner’s Curse: Why “Winning” Often Means You Just Lost with Nobel Laureate Richard Thaler (#288)
People say, oh, next year, fine.
3 Takeaways™
The Winner’s Curse: Why “Winning” Often Means You Just Lost with Nobel Laureate Richard Thaler (#288)
And it's from the raise, right?
3 Takeaways™
The Winner’s Curse: Why “Winning” Often Means You Just Lost with Nobel Laureate Richard Thaler (#288)
So there's no loss.