Scott Amatuccio

Eventually, Scott pieces together that no one has seen or spoken to Michael in 2 and 1 half years. He decides it's time to reach out to Michael's sister in upstate New York to compare notes.

Eventually, Scott pieces together that no one has seen or spoken to Michael in 2 and 1 half years. He decides it's time to reach out to Michael's sister in upstate New York to compare notes.

With his suspicions growing, Scott does what any of us might do when trying to track down his now long-lost friend. He logs onto Facebook.

With his suspicions growing, Scott does what any of us might do when trying to track down his now long-lost friend. He logs onto Facebook.

Scott then does a reverse Google image search, trying to determine where this photo came from. Turns out, it matches a photo from a Bloody Mary mix company.

Scott then does a reverse Google image search, trying to determine where this photo came from. Turns out, it matches a photo from a Bloody Mary mix company.

And Michael's recent posts also seemed off. They were different from what he typically posted in the past.

And Michael's recent posts also seemed off. They were different from what he typically posted in the past.

Michael's friend Scott, along with his sister Stacy, knew it was time for something drastic.

Michael's friend Scott, along with his sister Stacy, knew it was time for something drastic.

Scott is able to convince police in Florida that his concerns are serious enough to warrant a welfare check. And when a deputy goes to Lori Shaver's house, something catches his eye that's been hiding in plain sight for years.

Scott is able to convince police in Florida that his concerns are serious enough to warrant a welfare check. And when a deputy goes to Lori Shaver's house, something catches his eye that's been hiding in plain sight for years.

I'll take you there to see for yourself.

I'll take you there to see for yourself.

And just when you think you know where the story is headed, a new twist.

And just when you think you know where the story is headed, a new twist.

When you walked out here, were you immediately surprised? I really started to get chills up my back. But what about the chills when a totally unexpected person confesses? Everyone was just like, what? When you have a witness take the stand that says, I had a role in it, that's pretty incredible. I know it sounds weird.

When you walked out here, were you immediately surprised? I really started to get chills up my back. But what about the chills when a totally unexpected person confesses? Everyone was just like, what? When you have a witness take the stand that says, I had a role in it, that's pretty incredible. I know it sounds weird.

It's been two and a half years since anyone has seen or spoken to Michael Shaver. His loved ones are concerned. So his longtime friend, Scott Amatuccio, decides to call law enforcement. He requests a welfare check.

It's been two and a half years since anyone has seen or spoken to Michael Shaver. His loved ones are concerned. So his longtime friend, Scott Amatuccio, decides to call law enforcement. He requests a welfare check.