Menu
Sign In Search Podcasts Charts People & Topics Add Podcast API Blog Pricing

Senator Chris Murphy

๐Ÿ‘ค Speaker
1545 total appearances

Appearances Over Time

Podcast Appearances

The Megyn Kelly Show
Scott Peterson May Get a New Trial - A Look Back at the Case: A "True Crime Christmas" Special | Ep. 975

I've done a lot of cases like this, which are bifurcated murder trials. The juries take their task very seriously. The judges tend to be the most experienced and the best. The detectives tend to be the most experienced and the best. And it's imperfect. But everybody really wants to do their job. So then a couple of decades later and say it's a homeless drifter.

The Megyn Kelly Show
Scott Peterson May Get a New Trial - A Look Back at the Case: A "True Crime Christmas" Special | Ep. 975

I've done a lot of cases like this, which are bifurcated murder trials. The juries take their task very seriously. The judges tend to be the most experienced and the best. The detectives tend to be the most experienced and the best. And it's imperfect. But everybody really wants to do their job. So then a couple of decades later and say it's a homeless drifter.

The Megyn Kelly Show
Scott Peterson May Get a New Trial - A Look Back at the Case: A "True Crime Christmas" Special | Ep. 975

OK, and that guy is convicted and maybe he's got some some sex offenses in his past. And the way it works over and over again is he'll say, hey, it was consensual sex. I understand that she's a stockbroker and I was living in a tent. But trust me, we really had a spark. And boy, did we hit it off. And so that's why my sperm was found all over the place.

The Megyn Kelly Show
Scott Peterson May Get a New Trial - A Look Back at the Case: A "True Crime Christmas" Special | Ep. 975

OK, and that guy is convicted and maybe he's got some some sex offenses in his past. And the way it works over and over again is he'll say, hey, it was consensual sex. I understand that she's a stockbroker and I was living in a tent. But trust me, we really had a spark. And boy, did we hit it off. And so that's why my sperm was found all over the place.

The Megyn Kelly Show
Scott Peterson May Get a New Trial - A Look Back at the Case: A "True Crime Christmas" Special | Ep. 975

OK, and that guy is convicted and maybe he's got some some sex offenses in his past. And the way it works over and over again is he'll say, hey, it was consensual sex. I understand that she's a stockbroker and I was living in a tent. But trust me, we really had a spark. And boy, did we hit it off. And so that's why my sperm was found all over the place.

The Megyn Kelly Show
Scott Peterson May Get a New Trial - A Look Back at the Case: A "True Crime Christmas" Special | Ep. 975

But somebody else came along later and killed her. And that will be the absurd, ridiculous defense that they will run and the jury will reject it properly and he'll get convicted. And then what happens is that, you know, that the DNA comes back like 20 years later or 30 years later, and they'll test the scrapings under her fingernails or they'll test some object that's found at the crime scene.

The Megyn Kelly Show
Scott Peterson May Get a New Trial - A Look Back at the Case: A "True Crime Christmas" Special | Ep. 975

But somebody else came along later and killed her. And that will be the absurd, ridiculous defense that they will run and the jury will reject it properly and he'll get convicted. And then what happens is that, you know, that the DNA comes back like 20 years later or 30 years later, and they'll test the scrapings under her fingernails or they'll test some object that's found at the crime scene.

The Megyn Kelly Show
Scott Peterson May Get a New Trial - A Look Back at the Case: A "True Crime Christmas" Special | Ep. 975

But somebody else came along later and killed her. And that will be the absurd, ridiculous defense that they will run and the jury will reject it properly and he'll get convicted. And then what happens is that, you know, that the DNA comes back like 20 years later or 30 years later, and they'll test the scrapings under her fingernails or they'll test some object that's found at the crime scene.

The Megyn Kelly Show
Scott Peterson May Get a New Trial - A Look Back at the Case: A "True Crime Christmas" Special | Ep. 975

And, you know, if she pat, if she patted a little boy on the head, that day, or if she shook hands with her mailman or something, you can discover unknown male DNA that has no link whatsoever to the actual murder. But the standard on appeal is could a jury, could a reasonable jury have found differently? Essentially, could they have

The Megyn Kelly Show
Scott Peterson May Get a New Trial - A Look Back at the Case: A "True Crime Christmas" Special | Ep. 975

And, you know, if she pat, if she patted a little boy on the head, that day, or if she shook hands with her mailman or something, you can discover unknown male DNA that has no link whatsoever to the actual murder. But the standard on appeal is could a jury, could a reasonable jury have found differently? Essentially, could they have

The Megyn Kelly Show
Scott Peterson May Get a New Trial - A Look Back at the Case: A "True Crime Christmas" Special | Ep. 975

And, you know, if she pat, if she patted a little boy on the head, that day, or if she shook hands with her mailman or something, you can discover unknown male DNA that has no link whatsoever to the actual murder. But the standard on appeal is could a jury, could a reasonable jury have found differently? Essentially, could they have

The Megyn Kelly Show
Scott Peterson May Get a New Trial - A Look Back at the Case: A "True Crime Christmas" Special | Ep. 975

could they have come to a different result based on that new evidence? And the answer under those circumstances is, yeah, if they didn't consider that, maybe so. So that's the standard for reversal on appeal. So the case comes back for a retrial and

The Megyn Kelly Show
Scott Peterson May Get a New Trial - A Look Back at the Case: A "True Crime Christmas" Special | Ep. 975

could they have come to a different result based on that new evidence? And the answer under those circumstances is, yeah, if they didn't consider that, maybe so. So that's the standard for reversal on appeal. So the case comes back for a retrial and

The Megyn Kelly Show
Scott Peterson May Get a New Trial - A Look Back at the Case: A "True Crime Christmas" Special | Ep. 975

could they have come to a different result based on that new evidence? And the answer under those circumstances is, yeah, if they didn't consider that, maybe so. So that's the standard for reversal on appeal. So the case comes back for a retrial and

The Megyn Kelly Show
Scott Peterson May Get a New Trial - A Look Back at the Case: A "True Crime Christmas" Special | Ep. 975

Aunt Millie, who worked in the evidence room, put it in the wrong box or the evidence got washed away in the great flood of 82 or and they can't redo it or the critical witnesses have died. The investigator necessary to lay the foundation for that evidence has has passed away. Like you can have this entire host of problems that can afflict a case like that 30 years later. So they they can't.

The Megyn Kelly Show
Scott Peterson May Get a New Trial - A Look Back at the Case: A "True Crime Christmas" Special | Ep. 975

Aunt Millie, who worked in the evidence room, put it in the wrong box or the evidence got washed away in the great flood of 82 or and they can't redo it or the critical witnesses have died. The investigator necessary to lay the foundation for that evidence has has passed away. Like you can have this entire host of problems that can afflict a case like that 30 years later. So they they can't.

The Megyn Kelly Show
Scott Peterson May Get a New Trial - A Look Back at the Case: A "True Crime Christmas" Special | Ep. 975

Aunt Millie, who worked in the evidence room, put it in the wrong box or the evidence got washed away in the great flood of 82 or and they can't redo it or the critical witnesses have died. The investigator necessary to lay the foundation for that evidence has has passed away. Like you can have this entire host of problems that can afflict a case like that 30 years later. So they they can't.

The Megyn Kelly Show
Scott Peterson May Get a New Trial - A Look Back at the Case: A "True Crime Christmas" Special | Ep. 975

retry it. And then what happens is you've got people like Barry Sheck in front of the cameras going another innocent man exonerated, which is the term they love, exonerated from DNA evidence when they weren't exonerated at all. They were they were granted a new trial and the prosecution couldn't proceed. And then that guy goes out.

The Megyn Kelly Show
Scott Peterson May Get a New Trial - A Look Back at the Case: A "True Crime Christmas" Special | Ep. 975

retry it. And then what happens is you've got people like Barry Sheck in front of the cameras going another innocent man exonerated, which is the term they love, exonerated from DNA evidence when they weren't exonerated at all. They were they were granted a new trial and the prosecution couldn't proceed. And then that guy goes out.

The Megyn Kelly Show
Scott Peterson May Get a New Trial - A Look Back at the Case: A "True Crime Christmas" Special | Ep. 975

retry it. And then what happens is you've got people like Barry Sheck in front of the cameras going another innocent man exonerated, which is the term they love, exonerated from DNA evidence when they weren't exonerated at all. They were they were granted a new trial and the prosecution couldn't proceed. And then that guy goes out.