Menu
Sign In Search Podcasts Libraries Charts People & Topics Add Podcast API Blog Pricing

Talisa Siganto

๐Ÿ‘ค Speaker
153 total appearances

Appearances Over Time

Podcast Appearances

The Case Of
03 Maree Crabtree | What did the note mean?

Effectively.

The Case Of
03 Maree Crabtree | What did the note mean?

So after eight hours of deliberating, they can be given a more formal direction.

The Case Of
03 Maree Crabtree | What did the note mean?

Just to say, you know, it's important that you go into the jury room and really consider this evidence as a whole and try and come to a unanimous decision.

The Case Of
03 Maree Crabtree | What did the note mean?

It's very similar to what they're told at the beginning of their deliberations, but there is an official direction that they can be given.

The Case Of
03 Maree Crabtree | What did the note mean?

Basically, they just need to take their time and not try and rush to a verdict.

The Case Of
03 Maree Crabtree | What did the note mean?

So there was a second note to the judge on the second day of deliberations, which did point to this idea that they were probably struggling with the consideration of Tara's evidence.

The Case Of
03 Maree Crabtree | What did the note mean?

They asked if they could watch a large portion of her testimony again.

The Case Of
03 Maree Crabtree | What did the note mean?

And this does happen sometimes in trials at the end when juries are deliberating, they want to see some things again.

The Case Of
03 Maree Crabtree | What did the note mean?

This took some hours, so there was a number of things that they wanted to re-listen to that she said.

The Case Of
03 Maree Crabtree | What did the note mean?

They were eventually sent home again at the end of that day, and they did tell the judge that they were well entrenched in their deliberations.

The Case Of
03 Maree Crabtree | What did the note mean?

They said that they just don't think that they can come to a unanimous decision.

The Case Of
03 Maree Crabtree | What did the note mean?

We know ultimately, as you said, they did come to their verdict on the third day they deliberated.

The Case Of
03 Maree Crabtree | What did the note mean?

So we can probably safely assume that evidence they rewatched did help them get to that decision.

The Case Of
03 Maree Crabtree | What did the note mean?

I think it certainly would have left them with a lot to think about.

The Case Of
03 Maree Crabtree | What did the note mean?

It was interesting to me that it wasn't brought up earlier in the trial.

The Case Of
03 Maree Crabtree | What did the note mean?

Even the judge commented on the fact that it wasn't raised during the opening addresses when the jury wasn't present.

The Case Of
03 Maree Crabtree | What did the note mean?

But look, Stockie, there was so much that came out during this trial.

The Case Of
03 Maree Crabtree | What did the note mean?

The jury had to consider a lot.

The Case Of
03 Maree Crabtree | What did the note mean?

I don't envy them.

The Case Of
03 Maree Crabtree | What did the note mean?

It was a very big task.