Unnamed Friend

I seen this old man and he had a metal detector. It was weird, you know.

Heather went from curious to off-the-charts suspicious. And then she got her hands on a recording of an anonymous phone call made to the sheriff's office. The caller claimed to know the location of Karen's body when she was still a missing person. Heather believed the voice on that call was Daryl Sells.

Heather went from curious to off-the-charts suspicious. And then she got her hands on a recording of an anonymous phone call made to the sheriff's office. The caller claimed to know the location of Karen's body when she was still a missing person. Heather believed the voice on that call was Daryl Sells.

Take a look at it and see if you can find out.

Take a look at it and see if you can find out.

Soon, Heather was convinced Daryl Sells was engaged in a huge cover-up to protect his own family.

Soon, Heather was convinced Daryl Sells was engaged in a huge cover-up to protect his own family.

Yes, it was just a theory, but that didn't stop Heather. She continued doing podcasts about the cells.

Yes, it was just a theory, but that didn't stop Heather. She continued doing podcasts about the cells.

And pretty soon, people in Dyersburg knew all about Heather's theories.

And pretty soon, people in Dyersburg knew all about Heather's theories.

She stirred up a hornet's nest, all right. And when you do that, you'd better be ready to get stung. You're accused of repeatedly threatening Heather Cohen, and including threatening to crush her skull. Heather Cohen thought she'd found the key to unlock the Karen Swift murder mystery.

She stirred up a hornet's nest, all right. And when you do that, you'd better be ready to get stung. You're accused of repeatedly threatening Heather Cohen, and including threatening to crush her skull. Heather Cohen thought she'd found the key to unlock the Karen Swift murder mystery.

Heather's theory about the murder started with the tip alleging that Karen Swift was having an affair with Daryl Sells' son-in-law, Bentley. Heather tried to get Bentley and his wife, Dina, to talk to her. They wouldn't do it. But Dina did talk to us. Heather Cohen said that Bentley was having an affair with Karen. False. But what do you think of that? How did he react to that?

Heather's theory about the murder started with the tip alleging that Karen Swift was having an affair with Daryl Sells' son-in-law, Bentley. Heather tried to get Bentley and his wife, Dina, to talk to her. They wouldn't do it. But Dina did talk to us. Heather Cohen said that Bentley was having an affair with Karen. False. But what do you think of that? How did he react to that?

Another of Heather's lies, according to Dina, was that story about a supposed fight between her and Karen at the Halloween party.

Another of Heather's lies, according to Dina, was that story about a supposed fight between her and Karen at the Halloween party.

Dina told us she and Bentley didn't even know Karen Swift.

Dina told us she and Bentley didn't even know Karen Swift.

But what about those witnesses who said Dina's father, Daryl Selves, was poking around the crime scene with a metal detector? Ridiculous, said Dina.