Menu
Sign In Search Podcasts Charts People & Topics Add Podcast API Blog Pricing

Will Baude

๐Ÿ‘ค Speaker
1738 total appearances

Appearances Over Time

Podcast Appearances

Divided Argument
The Marshal and the Margarine

But... Okay.

Divided Argument
The Marshal and the Margarine

Okay, so Kavanaugh's concurrence in the judgment agrees with part of what we just described, but not all of it.

Divided Argument
The Marshal and the Margarine

Government loses.

Divided Argument
The Marshal and the Margarine

And he also implies that as soon as the president does that, he's likely going to think we should defer to it.

Divided Argument
The Marshal and the Margarine

And given his general attitude towards executive power, pretty pro-executive power, justice.

Divided Argument
The Marshal and the Margarine

You know, I don't know whether he would think that it's conclusive that the president just makes that determination or just gets tremendous weight.

Divided Argument
The Marshal and the Margarine

But it would be a very different case for him.

Divided Argument
The Marshal and the Margarine

Very, very different case.

Divided Argument
The Marshal and the Margarine

They don't rule that out.

Divided Argument
The Marshal and the Margarine

But here, I mean, the court has already ruled out that this particular function constitutes executing the loss, right?

Divided Argument
The Marshal and the Margarine

Or at least strongly suggested that that's ruled out.

Divided Argument
The Marshal and the Margarine

So, I mean, there's not like a presidential determination with respect to that that would change the result here.