NIO's Battery Philosophy vs Waymo's Safety Crisis vs Li Auto's Reset

Three major stories from December 9, 2025 reveal fundamentally different strategic approaches as Chinese EV companies and autonomous driving firms face an increasingly brutal 2026 market. This episode analyzes NIO's battery philosophy, Waymo's safety crisis, and Li Auto's organizational reset to determine which strategy will succeed long-term.NIO's Onvo president Shen Fei stated in a December 8 interview that extended-range electric vehicles with large battery packs represent a waste of resources. His argument is that with charging infrastructure increasingly developed in China, EREVs with large battery packs not only sacrifice interior space but also create unnecessary cost burdens, adding approximately 15,000 REN per range extender for automakers and consumers. Shen explained that EREVs and battery-swap-enabled vehicles compete on different dimensions, with larger batteries and fuel tanks representing incremental innovation while battery swapping constitutes systemic innovation requiring companies to address numerous challenges.Supporting this philosophy, approximately 40 percent of Onvo L90 owners, which comes standard with an 85 kWh battery pack, downgrade to the lower-capacity 60 kWh pack, saving about 3,600 REN in annual battery rental costs. Shen noted most owners no longer experience range anxiety thanks to charging infrastructure expansion. This contrasts with recent competitor launches including Leapmotor's D19 large SUV with 80 kWh battery, the largest among Chinese EREVs, and XPeng's X9 EREV with 63.3 kWh battery offering 452 km CLTC range.On December 5, Onvo announced deployment of over 8,000 new battery packs in battery swap stations available to its vehicles, with completion expected by mid-January 2026. Currently, Onvo accesses 2,300 NIO battery swap stations housing approximately 7,000 battery packs. Beyond serving vehicle owners, these batteries generate revenue by providing grid services. In Zhejiang province, each battery earns approximately 1.2 REN per kWh, with average usable capacity of 50 kWh generating roughly 60 REN daily or 20,000 REN annually per battery.Waymo faces a major safety crisis after the US National Highway Traffic Safety Administration forced a software recall following 19 incidents of Waymo autonomous vehicles illegally passing school buses with flashing red lights and extended stop signs during student pickup and dropoff. US traffic laws mandate all vehicles stop immediately when school buses activate red warning lights, with violations carrying 1,000 dollar fines for human drivers. The Austin Independent School District requested Waymo suspend operations during critical school hours, but Waymo refused, citing disagreement with the district's risk assessment and defending operations using its safety record.After claiming a November 17 software update fixed the vulnerability, five additional violations occurred within two weeks. The Austin school district reported 19 total recorded incidents since the 2025-26 school year began. When questioned by NHTSA about ceasing operations, software fix effectiveness, and recall plans, Waymo was required to respond by January 20, 2026. Waymo Chief Safety Officer Mauricio Peña emphasized internal statistics showing pedestrian injury accident incidence one-twelfth that of human drivers while announcing voluntary software recall for appropriately slowing and stopping in relevant scenarios.Waymo's aggressive expansion across San Francisco, Los Angeles, Phoenix, Austin, Atlanta with planned 2026 entry into Las Vegas, San Diego, and Detroit has been accompanied by numerous safety incidents. NHTSA data shows at least 14 animal collision incidents. Local residents report Waymo vehicles transformed from overly courteous to aggressive behavior including weaving through tunnels, incomplete stops at stop signs, squeezing past vehicles, and illegal U-turns. When asked why Robotaxi became increasingly aggressive, Chris Ludwick, Waymo Senior

There are no comments yet.

Please log in to write the first comment.