The Mike Hosking Breakfast

Mike's Minute: It's time to mix up the election debate format

28 Sep 2023

Audio

Description

Based on the premise that you learn from your mistakes and the general idea that you want to improve, the conclusion I have reached this week as another seven days in the campaign ends is we need to have a good long think about the debates. I am not alone. Several pieces I have now read say essentially the same thing. Debate one was widely panned as being boring, unproductive, and certainly lacking any illumination. Debate two was criticised for being a yell fest, where one candidate was determined to out-shout the other. And for his efforts he got awarded the prize from the so-called experts as the winner. Then you had the other debates; the minor leader's debate was another yell fest in a pub. In the youth debate there was more yelling. Then, for my sins, to give some perspective I watched yesterday's second debate in the states with the Republicans. I watched the first debate with the Republicans as well. What you conclude from the American scenario is they don’t do a lot better than we do. The mistake in the first one was there were too many people on stage and too many moderators, they had two of them. Yesterday there were seven candidates and three moderators. The advantage the Americans might have is talent and budget. In a country of 300+ million, surely the best broadcasters are better than ours? The truth is, not really. The three yesterday had one talent and two second-raters. They got around the yelling of candidates by holding it in a massive space, the Ronald Reagan Presidential Library, where if you turned the mic off you couldn’t hear them. But it did nothing for the debate itself. It was an unfulfilling, disjointed two hours I won't get back. And that seems, to me, to be the trouble with these things. If you follow politics you have heard it all before. If you don’t, you'd be forgiven for not voting because what you're watching is bollocks. So, here and in the great democracy of America debates seem dead. The format doesn’t seem to work anymore. As one writer said yesterday about Newshub's effort, it was more game show than game changer. They don’t add to the overall sum of things. We make much of them in the buildup and feel deflated with the experience. So let's learn from it. Come 2026, let's come up with something a lot different and a lot better than what this cluster has turned out to be. See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Transcription

This episode hasn't been transcribed yet

Help us prioritize this episode for transcription by upvoting it.

0 upvotes

🗳️ Sign in to Upvote

Popular episodes get transcribed faster

Other episodes from The Mike Hosking Breakfast

Transcribed and ready to explore now

Brad Olsen: Infometrics economist says Government's unrevealed $1B an 'odd approach'

08 Jun 2026

The Mike Hosking Breakfast

Sam Cliffe: NZ Blood Service CEO says more plasma donors are needed

07 Jun 2026

The Mike Hosking Breakfast

Heather du Plessis-Allan: Luxon does his best work overseas

07 Jun 2026

The Mike Hosking Breakfast

Full Show Podcast: 08 June 2026

07 Jun 2026

The Mike Hosking Breakfast

Richard Arnold: US Correspondent chats Iran, Graham Platner, and Trump storming out of NBC interview

07 Jun 2026

The Mike Hosking Breakfast

The Mike Hosking Breakfast

Mike's Minute: It's time to mix up the election debate format

This episode hasn't been transcribed yet

Other episodes from The Mike Hosking Breakfast

Brad Olsen: Infometrics economist says Government's unrevealed $1B an 'odd approach'

Sam Cliffe: NZ Blood Service CEO says more plasma donors are needed

Heather du Plessis-Allan: Luxon does his best work overseas

Full Show Podcast: 08 June 2026

Richard Arnold: US Correspondent chats Iran, Graham Platner, and Trump storming out of NBC interview

Christopher Luxon: Prime Minister says international role is 'super salesman for New Zealand'

Sign in to Audioscrape

Share this moment