The Mike Hosking Breakfast

Mike's Minute: Real estate deals shouldn't be race-based

30 Sep 2025

Audio

Description

The Dixon Street building debacle surely allows us to ask some questions of the Treaty process. If you missed it, Dixon St Apartments sold for a million dollars to local Māori under their Treaty deal – the Treaty deal had a first right of refusal clause. Now my assumption, clearly incorrect, is you would get first right of refusal based on the idea that something of cultural or historic significance was coming to the market, and as local iwi you wouldn’t want to miss the opportunity. I didn’t realise this was a commercial free for all, where anything and everything for sale goes to local Māori first. Further, I had assumed, clearly wrongly as well, that in having a first right of refusal, that meant that long lost treasure, whether historic or cultural, would be returned to said iwi to be honoured and looked after in perpetuity, not flicked off for quick profit. So obviously nothing like that is remotely part of the Treaty deals. So first question: why not? Next question is: if it isn't, is it commercially acceptable to have a race-based clause when it comes to real estate? And even if it is, is it commercially acceptable to sell stuff cheap? For if you haven't followed the story, five minutes after buying the building, the new owners sold it on for $3 million. So under a special deal signed for, on our behalf, by our government, we, the taxpayer, lose $2 million on one building. Next question: how could a Crown agency, i.e. Kainga Ora, think $1 million was a good price for something that was clearly worth $3 million? And in that is the problem with not involving the free market. Next question: did anyone involved in the cloistered deal know what they were doing, and if not, given its taxpayers’ dosh, why not? Another question: was the Treaty process designed so tribes could get into real estate speculation? At what point was a Treaty settlement about putting past wrongs right versus turning tribes into speculators? This was a bad deal. The original owners of Dixon St, us, got stiffed. And we got stiffed because of a race-based real estate clause that arguably should never have been part of an historic arrangement in the first place. Final question: what are we going to do about it? Or more worryingly, is there anything we can do about it? See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

Transcription

This episode hasn't been transcribed yet

Help us prioritize this episode for transcription by upvoting it.

0 upvotes

🗳️ Sign in to Upvote

Popular episodes get transcribed faster

Other episodes from The Mike Hosking Breakfast

Transcribed and ready to explore now

Mike's Minute: The only winner of the political polls

24 Jun 2026

The Mike Hosking Breakfast

Ben Glanfield and Jackson Boswell: Borderline members on their debut album, growing popularity

24 Jun 2026

The Mike Hosking Breakfast

Chris Kinraid: NZ Rugby Chief Financial Officer explains why they rejected bids to save Moana Pasifika

24 Jun 2026

The Mike Hosking Breakfast

Caroline Harvie-Teare: Venues Otautahi CEO on the new One NZ Stadium generating $21 million in the first 60 days

24 Jun 2026

The Mike Hosking Breakfast

Simon Bridges: Auckland Business Chamber CEO on the 12th annual China Business Summit taking place in Auckland

24 Jun 2026

The Mike Hosking Breakfast

The Mike Hosking Breakfast

Mike's Minute: Real estate deals shouldn't be race-based

This episode hasn't been transcribed yet

Other episodes from The Mike Hosking Breakfast

Mike's Minute: The only winner of the political polls

Ben Glanfield and Jackson Boswell: Borderline members on their debut album, growing popularity

Chris Kinraid: NZ Rugby Chief Financial Officer explains why they rejected bids to save Moana Pasifika

Caroline Harvie-Teare: Venues Otautahi CEO on the new One NZ Stadium generating $21 million in the first 60 days

Simon Bridges: Auckland Business Chamber CEO on the 12th annual China Business Summit taking place in Auckland

Jo McKenna: Europe Correspondent on the heatwave sweeping Europe, Meloni v Trump

Sign in to Audioscrape

Share this moment