Andrew Wilson

But do you have a duty to go fight a war if you get drafted?

Correct.

Oh, okay.

And yet they're privileged when it comes to custody and divorces.

They're privileged when it comes to child support.

They're privileged when it comes to alimony.

They're privileged when it comes to all of these things.

They have every advantage when it comes to having the child.

And so it's like, no- It's a different argument.

So it's an ontological argument.

The nature of woman is to have children.

The nature of men is to go to war.

Right.

And so... Then the woman needs to be fulfilling her nature then, right?

Yeah.

So then the duty is collective?

Yeah.

Then why isn't childbirth?

i don't i don't understand you're saying for women to have the right to vote they must have a duty to bear children yeah well if you're saying that there's a duty for men to go to war and you're saying that the reason that they do is because that's their ontological nature and the ontological nature of women is to have children okay i can concede that argument but we just ran into a problem then because if one is collective and then the other is collective why do i have to fulfill my duty but they don't have to fulfill theirs

But it's a collective duty for men to go, well, then again, that sounds like privilege.