Annie Elise

So there is an hour that is unaccounted for, which really doesn't leave you with a strong alibi.

Now, the blood on John's bedding was still pretty fresh.

So when you look at everything, it's not too far out there to believe that Nathan could have killed John, then went fishing with his mom in an attempt to make it seem like he was away from the scene of the crime and build an alibi.

But regardless of his alibi, when the investigation into John's murder was going on, neither of his aunts or the investigators believed him.

And I'm also not really sure how his mom Linda felt.

From day one, Nathan was locked in as the prime suspect.

In fact, at John's funeral, Nathan's Aunt Valerie was going around to all of the attendants saying that she knew that Nathan had murdered him.

All while Nathan was also in attendance at this funeral.

She just didn't care.

She was telling anybody who would listen.

And you know what?

I kind of respect that.

Like, you know, stand on ten toes.

I feel I like that.

Now, one of John's trusted employees, who had been a caretaker for one of his many properties, claimed that Valerie had come up to her at the funeral with this murder theory.

And when the caretaker asked Valerie why Nathan was with them at this funeral then, instead of sitting in a jail cell, Valerie's response was that he was never going to be prosecuted for it, that he would just be sent to a mental institution for the rest of his life.

So like I said, all eyes were on Nathan literally from day one.

Now, not everybody felt like Nathan being John's killer made sense.

John gave Nathan literally anything and everything that he ever wanted.

Money was never an issue.