Ash Kelley

Forgiveness is divine?

Forgiveness is divine?

You don't even know what we're arguing about.

Shut the fuck up.

You're uninformed, my guy.

You're very uninformed.

And I have more stupid Charlie shit in the book here.

Well, because even when he is informed, he doesn't really give a shit.

Oh, yeah.

Because I have another thing that just says Charlie in here.

um and this is in like a in the 300s range and it's after uh jacob has forced himself on bella kissing her yeah and which we'll get to that because that whole scene in the book is even more upsetting read that scene first because i think you need to hear how it's described in the book before you hear charlie's reaction all right so let me get to the to the part in the book not to direct you here i'm like hold on backtrack that

Because so even in the movie, just while you're looking for that, I'll go through it.

Even in the movie, like he kisses her forcefully.

And it's a lot in the movie.

But in the book, it is a million times worse.

And in the movie, it happens so fast.

And it's still upsetting.

But it's kind of like, but you're like, oh, God.

And she kind of pushes him away and is like, what the fuck?

And she punches him.