Betül Kaçar

very difficult to answer scientifically right you you are just you just took the problem away from this planet and formulated in a way that i cannot go and try to understand in the lab doing experiments or even through models does it though so i've heard brilliant biologists like yourself say that but i just to me okay here's how i think of earth

So I know the exact episodes of Star Trek you're talking about.

But that's not what panspermia is about.

You're talking about my proposition.

That's not what panspermia is.

I don't think panspermia usually articulates at the level of eukaryotes.

I think they talk about...

but bacteria primarily.

I think so.

Yeah, but it's... I mean, it's definitely...

interesting to listen to, but I wouldn't know how to place it in the studies of origin of life, I guess, or early life.

How do you answer that question?

How do you understand that with fundamentals of chemistry and physics?

But you're talking about panspermia, right?

Just, I don't understand how would you, it's different than, if you think it's similar to looking for life in the universe, is that what you're thinking?

But a whole entire organism is not a missing component like that, right?

I mean, when you're thinking about origin of life.

But... See, okay, so think... But, yeah.

I don't think so.

I mean, there will be, the failure is not going to indicate that this must have been, I don't think anyone will put the problem to something else just because our failures, our experiments failed.