Menu
Sign In Search Podcasts Libraries Charts People & Topics Add Podcast API Blog Pricing

Dan Neidle

👤 Speaker
197 total appearances

Appearances Over Time

Podcast Appearances

The Rest Is Money
286. Dan Neidle: Pubs don’t deserve a VAT cut

But yeah, pausing for a second.

The Rest Is Money
286. Dan Neidle: Pubs don’t deserve a VAT cut

Simply abolishing business rates for pubs is a really bad idea.

The Rest Is Money
286. Dan Neidle: Pubs don’t deserve a VAT cut

You're giving money to landlords.

The Rest Is Money
286. Dan Neidle: Pubs don’t deserve a VAT cut

Don't do it.

The Rest Is Money
286. Dan Neidle: Pubs don’t deserve a VAT cut

But there are other features of business rates that are problematic to tenants.

The Rest Is Money
286. Dan Neidle: Pubs don’t deserve a VAT cut

The biggest one is that the market adjusts quickly, but business rates adjustment is really slow.

The Rest Is Money
286. Dan Neidle: Pubs don’t deserve a VAT cut

And so if your business rates go up overnight, which often happens, that's not reducing your rent.

The Rest Is Money
286. Dan Neidle: Pubs don’t deserve a VAT cut

Yeah, a one year business rate holiday for pubs, for example, is not going to go through into rents, but a permanent one will.

The Rest Is Money
286. Dan Neidle: Pubs don’t deserve a VAT cut

There are better things that could be done that would actually help, like having more regular reviews of business rates.

The Rest Is Money
286. Dan Neidle: Pubs don’t deserve a VAT cut

You don't have this problem of business rates going up when the actual economic value of the property has fallen just because of the time lag between the valuation and the payment.

The Rest Is Money
286. Dan Neidle: Pubs don’t deserve a VAT cut

Yeah, I mean, the French system is mad.

The Rest Is Money
286. Dan Neidle: Pubs don’t deserve a VAT cut

Anyone listening, if you Google John Van Rienen, R-E-E-N-A-N, R-E-N-E-N, and French firm chart, you will see this most astonishing chart showing how you have a large number of French firms up to 50 employees.

The Rest Is Money
286. Dan Neidle: Pubs don’t deserve a VAT cut

And after that, the numbers just plummet because there are so many French rules that...

The Rest Is Money
286. Dan Neidle: Pubs don’t deserve a VAT cut

complicate stroke, punish the lives of businesses with 50 employees.

The Rest Is Money
286. Dan Neidle: Pubs don’t deserve a VAT cut

So drawing lines around small businesses is always a very attractive thing for politicians to do, but it's a very dangerous thing that can do quite serious damage.

The Rest Is Money
286. Dan Neidle: Pubs don’t deserve a VAT cut

I live in Norfolk and hospitality is, I don't know about the major, but a very major employer here.

The Rest Is Money
286. Dan Neidle: Pubs don’t deserve a VAT cut

And I talk to local businesses and people that run them.

The Rest Is Money
286. Dan Neidle: Pubs don’t deserve a VAT cut

And the two biggest complaints are

The Rest Is Money
286. Dan Neidle: Pubs don’t deserve a VAT cut

are the rise in the minimum wage and the rise in employer national insurance.

The Rest Is Money
286. Dan Neidle: Pubs don’t deserve a VAT cut

And it seems to me, if people are complaining about two things and saying two things are the problem, maybe politicians should be thinking about those two things and not about other things.