Dave Mack

Yeah, and I'll tell you, Nancy, one of the reasons why I personally and everyone on my team

uh spends quite a bit of time uh on interviews and in missing persons cases of anybody who saw uh this person around the time that they went missing the second point is that we spend quite a bit of time going back and asking the same questions again sometimes weeks sometimes months sometimes years later what we're looking for there is any inconsistencies has their story changed

And if so, where did it change?

And, you know, to have this gentleman say there wasn't a party, then there was a party.

She was there.

She wasn't there.

This is a major inconsistency that that should and ought to be looked into further.

Yeah, you've pointed this out, that Payne Lindsey has done the most exhaustive investigation of anybody related to this case, including the Blackfeet Law Enforcement Service and the FBI.

And going back this amount of time, we need to do exactly what Payne has done, re-interview folks that are connected to this case, because you have a number of people

who have extensive criminal records associated with the last moments that we're aware of Ashley's movements.

Those are, you know, circled and highlighted, red and yellow, need to be looked at here.

Yeah, and Tashina running Crane is also associated closely and I believe at least maybe romantically was involved with a person of interest that Sam indicated that Ashley was last seen with or dropped off to meet.

in that final day that he reported.

So, you know, the number of people around this case who have had numerous contacts with law enforcement on unrelated cases makes this very difficult to get a straight story out of them.

Yeah, near the time of her disappearance, it's been reported by Payne Lindsey that Ashley returned to her father's house in a state of panic, shutting the blinds, attempting to hide inside his residence, saying that something had happened that she needed to hide from.

So, you know, that's another key piece of information to add color to what was happening in those final days.

Beloved Oakland coffee shop owner vanishes without warning, leaving her daughters desperate for their mother's safe return.

I won't.

And what I'll say that, you know, this case is particularly alarming because of the time of day that Amy Hilliard went missing.

She was last seen at her home around 2 p.m.