Menu
Sign In Search Podcasts Charts People & Topics Add Podcast API Blog Pricing

David French

πŸ‘€ Speaker
1977 total appearances

Appearances Over Time

Podcast Appearances

The Opinions
ICE Is Splitting America in Two

Yeah, I think it's changing with more presidential control over a diminished executive branch.

The Opinions
ICE Is Splitting America in Two

So if you look at the totality of Supreme Court authority, and this couldβ€”this take, I fully acknowledge, could age very poorly depending on how the Tariff case comes out, how the Lisa Cook case comes out, how theβ€” You don't have to worry too much about that, right?

The Opinions
ICE Is Splitting America in Two

But by June, by the end of June, we'll know a whole lot more.

The Opinions
ICE Is Splitting America in Two

So that's when the Supreme Court issues all the opinions for this term.

The Opinions
ICE Is Splitting America in Two

But here's the way I would phrase it.

The Opinions
ICE Is Splitting America in Two

What the unitary executive theory says is the president has control over the executive branch.

The Opinions
ICE Is Splitting America in Two

However, the original separation of powers conception would say that the president doesn't have control over Congress.

The Opinions
ICE Is Splitting America in Two

And there's even limits as to what Congress can delegate to the president.

The Opinions
ICE Is Splitting America in Two

And so, for example, tariffs, that is a enumerated Article I authority of Congress.

The Opinions
ICE Is Splitting America in Two

Can Congress just delegate that to the president without using even those explicit terms to grant worldwide tariff taxing authority?

The Opinions
ICE Is Splitting America in Two

I think the answer to that is gonna be no.

The Opinions
ICE Is Splitting America in Two

Similarly, when you're talking about the Fed, the court has determined so far, at least in dicta, that the Fed is different from the SEC and the FTC.

The Opinions
ICE Is Splitting America in Two

And in that circumstance, the president doesn't have that unfettered authority.

The Opinions
ICE Is Splitting America in Two

Birthright citizenship, you have an actual constitutional provision and a statutory provision enacting birthright citizenship as we understand it.

The Opinions
ICE Is Splitting America in Two

I think they're gonna find that the president doesn't have the unilateral ability to change all that by executive decree.

The Opinions
ICE Is Splitting America in Two

So I would say that the sort of originalist conception in which a majority of the majority is operating under is that the president, yes, should have more control over the executive branch

The Opinions
ICE Is Splitting America in Two

However, the executive branch should have less control over the American government.

The Opinions
ICE Is Splitting America in Two

And I think that that is where they're heading.

The Opinions
ICE Is Splitting America in Two

And so what that will mean is Trump is gonna, at the end of the day, have more ability to hire and fire, say, the head of any given agency or independent agency other than the Fed, but those agencies are gonna have less power to do what Trump wants them to do.

The Opinions
ICE Is Splitting America in Two

Now, I think that's gonna be the ultimate resolution by June 30th of 2026 of this year.