Menu
Sign In Search Podcasts Charts People & Topics Add Podcast API Blog Pricing

Domenico Montanaro

๐Ÿ‘ค Speaker
See mentions of this person in podcasts
2114 total appearances

Appearances Over Time

Podcast Appearances

The NPR Politics Podcast
SCOTUS hears birthright citizenship arguments

You know, Justice Kavanaugh sort of talked about public opinion in some respects as not really legally relevant.

The NPR Politics Podcast
SCOTUS hears birthright citizenship arguments

Right.

The NPR Politics Podcast
SCOTUS hears birthright citizenship arguments

He said that, you know, whether other countries have it or not, which is one of the arguments that the Trump administration makes that D. John Sauer, the solicitor general, had brought up.

The NPR Politics Podcast
SCOTUS hears birthright citizenship arguments

He said, I'm not seeing the relevance as a legal interpretive matter.

The NPR Politics Podcast
SCOTUS hears birthright citizenship arguments

And Sauer, for his credit to his credit, agreed with that.

The NPR Politics Podcast
SCOTUS hears birthright citizenship arguments

It's not relevant, but it's relevant to what happens outside and what you're seeing outside of the court.

The NPR Politics Podcast
SCOTUS hears birthright citizenship arguments

are big crowds, people who have strong feelings and passions about this that are also relevant to, one, President Trump, but also, two, what it means to be American and what the redefinition is of what this country is going to stand for as far as who belongs here.

The NPR Politics Podcast
SCOTUS hears birthright citizenship arguments

And because at the time that this 14th Amendment was passed, as some of the justices and the

The NPR Politics Podcast
SCOTUS hears birthright citizenship arguments

And Cecilia Wong from the ACLU had noted, you know, this was a time when they were the United States was still growing and needed more people and needed to, you know, kind of go out into the other parts of the country and build up.

The NPR Politics Podcast
SCOTUS hears birthright citizenship arguments

That's a different is a different United States now than it was then.

The NPR Politics Podcast
SCOTUS hears birthright citizenship arguments

The question is, can you change that through the Supreme Court or do you change that through Congress?

The NPR Politics Podcast
SCOTUS hears birthright citizenship arguments

I thought this idea of legally domiciled was really at the key of this entire argument.

The NPR Politics Podcast
SCOTUS hears birthright citizenship arguments

And if you were to keyword how many times the word domicile got used, there would be many, right?

The NPR Politics Podcast
SCOTUS hears birthright citizenship arguments

And I think that this is an interesting point because โ€“

The NPR Politics Podcast
SCOTUS hears birthright citizenship arguments

What does it mean to be legally domiciled, right?

The NPR Politics Podcast
SCOTUS hears birthright citizenship arguments

Like what does it mean โ€“ it's not necessarily citizenship or bloodline, right?

The NPR Politics Podcast
SCOTUS hears birthright citizenship arguments

So does it mean somebody who's been in the country for decades, et cetera?

The NPR Politics Podcast
SCOTUS hears birthright citizenship arguments

Well, I think that's notable that he was there from a legacy standpoint and from what he values, right?

The NPR Politics Podcast
SCOTUS hears birthright citizenship arguments

Because he said that he talked about potentially maybe wanting to go to the tariffs case at the Supreme Court.

The NPR Politics Podcast
SCOTUS hears birthright citizenship arguments

He ultimately decided against doing that.