Josh Mankiewicz

Police looked into the alleged affair and say Bill's phone records appear to confirm his account. And wouldn't it have been very hard for him to give her the colchicine in an appropriate time frame unless you believe that she got it like 12 hours earlier or something like that?

Police looked into the alleged affair and say Bill's phone records appear to confirm his account. And wouldn't it have been very hard for him to give her the colchicine in an appropriate time frame unless you believe that she got it like 12 hours earlier or something like that?

He wasn't there. Yeah. They didn't have lunch together.

He wasn't there. Yeah. They didn't have lunch together.

So if you believe that this happened at lunchtime, which is what the prosecution says, then it's pretty much got to be Katie.

So if you believe that this happened at lunchtime, which is what the prosecution says, then it's pretty much got to be Katie.

Bill did not want to talk. We approached him, I'm sure.

Bill did not want to talk. We approached him, I'm sure.

Over the course of Katie's trials, both Adam and Bill... ended up with transactional immunity because they testified in front of a grand jury. Now, for people who have committed crimes, transactional immunity can be this giant gift because what essentially is, it says, we will not prosecute you for anything you admit to in this proceeding, in this session.

Over the course of Katie's trials, both Adam and Bill... ended up with transactional immunity because they testified in front of a grand jury. Now, for people who have committed crimes, transactional immunity can be this giant gift because what essentially is, it says, we will not prosecute you for anything you admit to in this proceeding, in this session.

So you better confess to everything because you will not be prosecuted for it under the law.

So you better confess to everything because you will not be prosecuted for it under the law.

So, you know, that suggests that Bill or Adam could not be charged, at least not based on whatever they said in the grand jury. But again, they didn't confess. Neither one of them said, yeah, I did it.

So, you know, that suggests that Bill or Adam could not be charged, at least not based on whatever they said in the grand jury. But again, they didn't confess. Neither one of them said, yeah, I did it.

The question is going to be whether Katie gets tried again, not whether somebody else gets tried. Absolutely. Up next, you, and by you, I mean the home listener, had a lot to say about who you thought killed Mary Yoder and about the investigation and about everything that happened. We will be right back with your questions from social media. OK, so this is not my story. This is your story.

The question is going to be whether Katie gets tried again, not whether somebody else gets tried. Absolutely. Up next, you, and by you, I mean the home listener, had a lot to say about who you thought killed Mary Yoder and about the investigation and about everything that happened. We will be right back with your questions from social media. OK, so this is not my story. This is your story.

But I got a tremendous amount of interest in your story on social media on Friday night. I mean, a lot of people ask me, like, what's going on here? What is this? Who is this? I'm like, you should be directing these questions to Andrea. Like, I'm actually not covering this. But. A lot of people very interested. Fred Hines on Facebook said, interesting show tonight.

But I got a tremendous amount of interest in your story on social media on Friday night. I mean, a lot of people ask me, like, what's going on here? What is this? Who is this? I'm like, you should be directing these questions to Andrea. Like, I'm actually not covering this. But. A lot of people very interested. Fred Hines on Facebook said, interesting show tonight.

It's really hard to know who the real killer was, which is one reason this was such a great episode. I suppose it comes down to just three people, husband, son, son's girlfriend. If no one outside the family was involved, then it has to be one of those three. Those would appear to be the possible choices, although, as we've discussed, Adam or Bill were not charged.

It's really hard to know who the real killer was, which is one reason this was such a great episode. I suppose it comes down to just three people, husband, son, son's girlfriend. If no one outside the family was involved, then it has to be one of those three. Those would appear to be the possible choices, although, as we've discussed, Adam or Bill were not charged.