Juju Chang

But that morning, he says he saw someone who made him do a double take.

A young woman walking down the street.

They passed the young woman and kept driving toward the Belmar Bridge.

Craig testifies that the woman was wearing a leather bomber jacket with a fur collar, a headscarf, and heels.

A couple days later, Craig tells the court he was with his son when they stopped by a 7-Eleven.

And on the front door was a picture of the woman he spotted by the bridge.

The defense pulls up a picture on the monitor.

It's Sarah's senior portrait.

She's wearing a black graduation drape.

She has a soft smile, her dimples showing.

Craig is confident that the person he saw on the bridge that morning was Sarah.

So according to the defense, that would mean Liam and Preston did not throw her off the bridge the night before.

Could Sarah actually be alive?

Craig testifies that the young woman he saw didn't look like she wanted to be seen and ducked into the alley.

But when the prosecution starts their cross-examination, they question the accuracy of Craig's story.

Craig tells the court that when he saw news that Sarah was missing, he didn't go to the police to report what he saw.

He talked to a private investigator first.

So Craig acknowledges he could be wrong about when he saw Sarah.

He could have seen the woman in the leather jacket on Friday, December 2nd, the day before Sarah was reported missing, on Saturday, December 3rd.

There was also the issue of what time Craig saw the car on the bridge that morning.