Narrator/Host

We were sitting down in a meeting with CID about this exact letter when we got the call to go out to Holly's apartment.

We were like, what is going on here?

It's like something you see in a movie.

The guy's trying to communicate with the police by way of mail.

And you're looking at the possibility this could be the same killer.

Of course, the same symbol is on the bottom of this letter that was written on the mirror in the hotel room in the lipstick.

So are we dealing with a copycat here?

We very much thought that it was a possibility these were connected.

Was Holly this killer's next victim, which would have been just a couple of weeks after Megan Tuma's murder?

So it was certainly of interest and of concern in the disappearance of Holly.

The public is demanding answers.

Now people are making phone calls.

They're calling the chief, the city council.

Hey, is there a serial killer in Fayetteville?

But as investigators dig deeper into the Megan Tuma case, they begin to question that serial killer theory.

Detectives are able to uncover evidence that her murder might have been a highly personal one.

and the trail leads to someone very close to her.

She had began a relationship with an individual, and she had become pregnant as a result of that relationship.

and we did a search one on his house, and you wouldn't believe it, he was actually actively taking a crime scene class at a local college here in Fayetteville.

Authorities began to close in on the man that they think might be responsible for Megan's murder.