Narrator/Host

Investigators believe the answer to that question lies in what they were told about John's alleged violent treatment of Holly.

We came out a couple of weeks on vacation to visit Holly, a couple of weeks before she was murdered.

And I met him again once there.

I just really didn't have a sense that there was anything until she began talking about a divorce.

Authorities come to learn that Holly filed for a protective order against John Wymonk in May, less than two months before she was killed, in which she alleged a chilling encounter with her husband.

We discovered that there had been an incident in the prior months leading up to this where he had threatened suicide and also held a gun to her head.

To her head?

Correct.

Threatening to kill her?

Yes.

After Holly did not show up for a court hearing on the protective order, the case was dismissed.

You need anything to drink?

Glass of water, sir.

Want some water?

Fair enough.

Despite the growing amount of evidence against John Weymouth implicating him in Holly's murder, Weymouth still will not talk.

Armed with the information that Kyle had given investigators, they gave John Wymack an opportunity to come clean and tell what happened.

He said he wasn't going to talk with them without an attorney present.

Follow me out here.

He was then charged with first-degree murder, second-degree arson, as well as conspiracy to commit second-degree arson.