Payton Moreland

So police go back to the county medical examiner and are like, hey, we need a second opinion on that autopsy. And when they look closer, they find the damage to her throat is not consistent with the injuries that are usually seen in self-strangulation cases. Which tells them this probably means another party was involved in this hanging.

They also learn there was another detail about that day that Michelle supposedly died. One Carrie seemingly left out when she told police about the big fight she had had with her mom. See, that same day that Michelle was found dead, she had just had a major victory in their court case. Something to do with the ongoing custody battle she had been engaging in with Lloyd for the youngest daughter.

They also learn there was another detail about that day that Michelle supposedly died. One Carrie seemingly left out when she told police about the big fight she had had with her mom. See, that same day that Michelle was found dead, she had just had a major victory in their court case. Something to do with the ongoing custody battle she had been engaging in with Lloyd for the youngest daughter.

They also learn there was another detail about that day that Michelle supposedly died. One Carrie seemingly left out when she told police about the big fight she had had with her mom. See, that same day that Michelle was found dead, she had just had a major victory in their court case. Something to do with the ongoing custody battle she had been engaging in with Lloyd for the youngest daughter.

which is just more confirmation to police that Michelle likely wouldn't have chosen to die by suicide, not after she had just made huge progress in this custody case. But more importantly, when they learn this, it made them question the 19-year-old daughter, Carrie. So they get a copy of Carrie's phone records because they want to corroborate this story she initially told them.

which is just more confirmation to police that Michelle likely wouldn't have chosen to die by suicide, not after she had just made huge progress in this custody case. But more importantly, when they learn this, it made them question the 19-year-old daughter, Carrie. So they get a copy of Carrie's phone records because they want to corroborate this story she initially told them.

which is just more confirmation to police that Michelle likely wouldn't have chosen to die by suicide, not after she had just made huge progress in this custody case. But more importantly, when they learn this, it made them question the 19-year-old daughter, Carrie. So they get a copy of Carrie's phone records because they want to corroborate this story she initially told them.

She said she wasn't at her mom's house for very long that night, only about 15 minutes before she took her sister, got in the car and drove to her apartment in Rochester to spend the weekend. But the phone records show Carrie was at her mom's house for a lot longer than she said, more likely two hours in the house before she left.

She said she wasn't at her mom's house for very long that night, only about 15 minutes before she took her sister, got in the car and drove to her apartment in Rochester to spend the weekend. But the phone records show Carrie was at her mom's house for a lot longer than she said, more likely two hours in the house before she left.

She said she wasn't at her mom's house for very long that night, only about 15 minutes before she took her sister, got in the car and drove to her apartment in Rochester to spend the weekend. But the phone records show Carrie was at her mom's house for a lot longer than she said, more likely two hours in the house before she left.

oh here we go they're like well like that's a pretty obvious lie you would know 15 minutes versus two hours you might not know an hour and a half versus two hours so they're like this is an obvious lie she obviously lied and the fact that her mother according to the autopsy died that same night or in the early morning red flags man here we go that puts some suspicion on Carrie and her story.

oh here we go they're like well like that's a pretty obvious lie you would know 15 minutes versus two hours you might not know an hour and a half versus two hours so they're like this is an obvious lie she obviously lied and the fact that her mother according to the autopsy died that same night or in the early morning red flags man here we go that puts some suspicion on Carrie and her story.

oh here we go they're like well like that's a pretty obvious lie you would know 15 minutes versus two hours you might not know an hour and a half versus two hours so they're like this is an obvious lie she obviously lied and the fact that her mother according to the autopsy died that same night or in the early morning red flags man here we go that puts some suspicion on Carrie and her story.

So the question for investigators was, would Carrie have done something like this alone? The other sister was there. So this is why the police speak with her again. And this time she tells them, okay, Actually, my dad wasn't in California that weekend. She's feeling pressure from police. And so she gives up this lie and says he was actually back by that point.

So the question for investigators was, would Carrie have done something like this alone? The other sister was there. So this is why the police speak with her again. And this time she tells them, okay, Actually, my dad wasn't in California that weekend. She's feeling pressure from police. And so she gives up this lie and says he was actually back by that point.

So the question for investigators was, would Carrie have done something like this alone? The other sister was there. So this is why the police speak with her again. And this time she tells them, okay, Actually, my dad wasn't in California that weekend. She's feeling pressure from police. And so she gives up this lie and says he was actually back by that point.

And he was with me in Rochester helping me move into my new apartment. which means Lloyd's alibi is sort of scrubbed now, considering he was only a two-hour drive from his ex-wife's house on the night that she died, not all the way across the United States. And so that's when the police take a much closer look at the family's dynamics as a whole, because they're like, okay, there's lies going on.

And he was with me in Rochester helping me move into my new apartment. which means Lloyd's alibi is sort of scrubbed now, considering he was only a two-hour drive from his ex-wife's house on the night that she died, not all the way across the United States. And so that's when the police take a much closer look at the family's dynamics as a whole, because they're like, okay, there's lies going on.

And he was with me in Rochester helping me move into my new apartment. which means Lloyd's alibi is sort of scrubbed now, considering he was only a two-hour drive from his ex-wife's house on the night that she died, not all the way across the United States. And so that's when the police take a much closer look at the family's dynamics as a whole, because they're like, okay, there's lies going on.

We confront her. She doesn't really say, oh, yeah, I lied about that night. She said, well, I lied about my dad and his whereabouts. Right.