Peter Van Sant

The crash never made sense to Kelly Sutherland, especially when she observed Dick Dow's behavior.

Was Dick Dow emotionally devastated by what had happened?

If he was, he didn't show it.

Dick Dow moved away and no one heard much about him until someone came forward 11 years after the accident with a far more sinister story of what really happened that morning.

This woman's accusation next.

When Janet and Stephen Dow died in a car fire near their New Hampshire home 19 years ago, it was declared an accident.

The case was quickly closed.

But was it really an accident?

Or was it something else?

This woman, Karen Safian, claims to know.

Who do you believe is getting away with murder?

Dick Dow, Karen Safian's boyfriend of eight years.

At the time, he was the police chief of Whitefield, New Hampshire.

When she first met Dick Dow two years after the fire, she felt sorry for him.

It was 1984, and Safian was a single mom just out of college.

Safian says Dick Dow never talked about the accident until one night, five years into their relationship.

Karen says Dick Dow then told her what really happened back in December 1982, a story he never told police investigators.

Dow said he had gone to the basement of his house to put coal in the furnace.

Did he say what he saw?

According to Safian, Dow said Steven had used one of his police revolvers to kill Janet.