Phoebe Judge

He pushed Mike overboard, as planned.

And that's where things stopped going, as planned.

And Mike didn't drown.

He actually swam to one of the stumps in the lake, clung onto the stump, and started screaming.

This was not what Brian had anticipated.

Brian had no idea what to do.

He said he felt he had no alternative.

He started the motor on his boat.

He circled Mike a few times getting closer and closer.

Then he lifted his gun and shot him in the head.

After that, he realized Mike's body can't be found with a bullet hole in his head.

You know, this is obviously not a drowning.

He realized he had to get rid of the body.

So he took one of Mike's feet in his hand.

He dragged the body to shore.

He pulled it up out of the lake.

He went to get his truck.

He lifted Mike's body into the tailgate of his truck.

Brian trained Labrador retrievers as a hobby, and he actually had a crate in the back of his truck, a dog crate, a big dog crate.

So he hauled Mike's body, shoved it into this dog crate in the back of his truck, slammed the truck shut, and drove as fast as he could to Tallahassee.