Menu
Sign In Search Podcasts Charts People & Topics Add Podcast API Blog Pricing
257 total appearances

Appearances Over Time

Podcast Appearances

Ten Minute Halacha
A Woman Becoming a Shul President

So the Kasar Mishnah points out on the spot that when Chazal make that drash of Melech ve'lo Malchah, they only say Melech ve'lo Malchah.

Ten Minute Halacha
A Woman Becoming a Shul President

They don't say anything about all leadership positions.

Ten Minute Halacha
A Woman Becoming a Shul President

They don't say anything about Sererah.

Ten Minute Halacha
A Woman Becoming a Shul President

They just say Melech ve'lo Malchah, that a man can be a king, a woman cannot be a king.

Ten Minute Halacha
A Woman Becoming a Shul President

So Moshe in the Chuvah, in the Gros Moshe Yerdei Chalek Beis, Tuchuvah, Simen Mem Dalen, Simen Mem Hei, suggests that maybe the Rambam is based on the Gemara Yivama stuff, Mem Hei Amad Aleph.

Ten Minute Halacha
A Woman Becoming a Shul President

The Gemara Yivama says...

Ten Minute Halacha
A Woman Becoming a Shul President

that the Torah does not allow us to appoint a ger as a king, but not only that, a ger is not allowed to take any position of srarah either, any position of authority.

Ten Minute Halacha
A Woman Becoming a Shul President

And Ramosha says that the Rambam probably assumes that a ger and a woman have the same din, that just like a ger is not allowed to take a position of srarah, and it's not just the din of king, it's just that king is set up as the paradigmatic example of a position of srarah,

Ten Minute Halacha
A Woman Becoming a Shul President

but really any other position of serara would also be included.

Ten Minute Halacha
A Woman Becoming a Shul President

So too by a woman, when Hazal Darshan, Melech V'Lamelka, that's just a paradigmatic example of serara, but all types of serara would be asr.

Ten Minute Halacha
A Woman Becoming a Shul President

So a couple of things to point out over here.

Ten Minute Halacha
A Woman Becoming a Shul President

is how do you define Srarah?

Ten Minute Halacha
A Woman Becoming a Shul President

And then we have to deal with does everyone agree to the Rambam?

Ten Minute Halacha
A Woman Becoming a Shul President

So first in terms of how to define, right, the Rambam is clearly Machmir, that a woman cannot be in a position of Srarah.

Ten Minute Halacha
A Woman Becoming a Shul President

So what is Srarah?

Ten Minute Halacha
A Woman Becoming a Shul President

Can a woman be a head of school, of a principal of a girl's school?

Ten Minute Halacha
A Woman Becoming a Shul President

So I would imagine even in the most Haredi circles, women are principals of schools, right?

Ten Minute Halacha
A Woman Becoming a Shul President

So why is that allowed?

Ten Minute Halacha
A Woman Becoming a Shul President

Is that a position of Srarah?

Ten Minute Halacha
A Woman Becoming a Shul President

So, the definition of surah is a little bit tricky.