Menu
Sign In Search Podcasts Charts People & Topics Add Podcast API Blog Pricing

Rob

๐Ÿ‘ค Speaker
10621 total appearances

Appearances Over Time

Podcast Appearances

80,000 Hours Podcast
A Ukraine ceasefire could accidentally set Europe up for a bigger war | RAND's top Russia expert Samuel Charap

Do we actually desperately want to bend over backwards to achieve a ceasefire if we think that, in fact, that is only going to be the beginning of another stage of set of provocations or of risks that are created?

80,000 Hours Podcast
A Ukraine ceasefire could accidentally set Europe up for a bigger war | RAND's top Russia expert Samuel Charap

Maybe in a sense, I mean, it's horrific for Ukraine, but in a sense, you have Russia bogged down in this quagmire in Ukraine.

80,000 Hours Podcast
A Ukraine ceasefire could accidentally set Europe up for a bigger war | RAND's top Russia expert Samuel Charap

They don't have attention or resources to focus on anyone else to be hassling other countries.

80,000 Hours Podcast
A Ukraine ceasefire could accidentally set Europe up for a bigger war | RAND's top Russia expert Samuel Charap

So maybe that's actually quite a convenient place to leave them stuck.

80,000 Hours Podcast
A Ukraine ceasefire could accidentally set Europe up for a bigger war | RAND's top Russia expert Samuel Charap

So back when we spoke in 2022, you thought that the war was, as I understand, was primarily motivated by Russia's security fears, as you know, NATO encroachment and encirclement, as opposed to kind of a genuine ideological belief that Ukraine is and always has been Russian and that Ukrainian nationality is basically fake.

80,000 Hours Podcast
A Ukraine ceasefire could accidentally set Europe up for a bigger war | RAND's top Russia expert Samuel Charap

I guess since then, we've seen...

80,000 Hours Podcast
A Ukraine ceasefire could accidentally set Europe up for a bigger war | RAND's top Russia expert Samuel Charap

we've got like many years of track record of Russian behavior, including like forced Russification, child deportation on a very big scale.

80,000 Hours Podcast
A Ukraine ceasefire could accidentally set Europe up for a bigger war | RAND's top Russia expert Samuel Charap

Does the identity or nationalist motivation now seem kind of any more central to you than it did back then?

80,000 Hours Podcast
A Ukraine ceasefire could accidentally set Europe up for a bigger war | RAND's top Russia expert Samuel Charap

Right, right, right.

80,000 Hours Podcast
A Ukraine ceasefire could accidentally set Europe up for a bigger war | RAND's top Russia expert Samuel Charap

Do you think, in a sense, Russia's security position seems worse now, right?

80,000 Hours Podcast
A Ukraine ceasefire could accidentally set Europe up for a bigger war | RAND's top Russia expert Samuel Charap

NATO, in many ways, is more up in their business.

80,000 Hours Podcast
A Ukraine ceasefire could accidentally set Europe up for a bigger war | RAND's top Russia expert Samuel Charap

It's got a bigger border.

80,000 Hours Podcast
A Ukraine ceasefire could accidentally set Europe up for a bigger war | RAND's top Russia expert Samuel Charap

Europe is rearming.

80,000 Hours Podcast
A Ukraine ceasefire could accidentally set Europe up for a bigger war | RAND's top Russia expert Samuel Charap

The negativity towards Russia is enormous.

80,000 Hours Podcast
A Ukraine ceasefire could accidentally set Europe up for a bigger war | RAND's top Russia expert Samuel Charap

I guess, is it possible that, if anything, the security concerns are more salient to Russia now, perhaps, than they were years ago?

80,000 Hours Podcast
A Ukraine ceasefire could accidentally set Europe up for a bigger war | RAND's top Russia expert Samuel Charap

Because they've accidentally, I guess, weakened themselves.

80,000 Hours Podcast
A Ukraine ceasefire could accidentally set Europe up for a bigger war | RAND's top Russia expert Samuel Charap

I guess the reason why I ask about the balance of motivations is that I think so much of the discussion about how to achieve a ceasefire is focused on the โ€“ like assuaging Russian security fears angle.

80,000 Hours Podcast
A Ukraine ceasefire could accidentally set Europe up for a bigger war | RAND's top Russia expert Samuel Charap

If in fact the biggest โ€“ like I guess it's a very centralized authoritarian country in a way where Putin's personal opinions unfortunately carry so much sway.

80,000 Hours Podcast
A Ukraine ceasefire could accidentally set Europe up for a bigger war | RAND's top Russia expert Samuel Charap

If he just literally is like โ€“

80,000 Hours Podcast
A Ukraine ceasefire could accidentally set Europe up for a bigger war | RAND's top Russia expert Samuel Charap

incredibly motivated by absolute contempt for the notion of Ukrainian nationality and independence, then satisfying, like making pragmatic concessions on Ukrainian neutrality or bringing weapons back further from Russia's border, maybe that won't be the thing that will enable a ceasefire to get over the line.