Menu
Sign In Search Podcasts Charts People & Topics Add Podcast API Blog Pricing

Ryan Knudson

๐Ÿ‘ค Speaker
See mentions of this person in podcasts
2865 total appearances

Appearances Over Time

Podcast Appearances

The Journal.
Fertility Inc.: The Embryo Editing Dinner

For a long time, people doing IVF have had the option to screen for diseases like cystic fibrosis and Tay-Sachs.

The Journal.
Fertility Inc.: The Embryo Editing Dinner

But a new crop of embryo screening companies are promising much more than that.

The Journal.
Fertility Inc.: The Embryo Editing Dinner

One of these startups is a company called Orchid, which focuses on screening for disease risk.

The Journal.
Fertility Inc.: The Embryo Editing Dinner

That's the company's CEO in a promotional video.

The Journal.
Fertility Inc.: The Embryo Editing Dinner

Orchid provides information on a wide range of diseases, including complex conditions influenced by lots of genes, like Alzheimer's, bipolar disorder, and schizophrenia.

The Journal.
Fertility Inc.: The Embryo Editing Dinner

They charge $2,500 per embryo.

The Journal.
Fertility Inc.: The Embryo Editing Dinner

Brian Armstrong is one of Orchid's investors.

The Journal.
Fertility Inc.: The Embryo Editing Dinner

But while Orchid focuses on diseases, other startups go much further.

The Journal.
Fertility Inc.: The Embryo Editing Dinner

โ€” That was the CEO of a startup called Nucleus.

The Journal.
Fertility Inc.: The Embryo Editing Dinner

Its services start at about $10,000.

The Journal.
Fertility Inc.: The Embryo Editing Dinner

The company recently ran an ad campaign in New York City subways that included the tagline, Have Your Best Baby.

The Journal.
Fertility Inc.: The Embryo Editing Dinner

Scientists and bioethicists have accused some of these startups of essentially marketing eugenics.

The Journal.
Fertility Inc.: The Embryo Editing Dinner

They've also questioned the accuracy of some of these tests.

The Journal.
Fertility Inc.: The Embryo Editing Dinner

But unlike embryo editing, embryo screening is perfectly legal in the U.S.

The Journal.
Fertility Inc.: The Embryo Editing Dinner

And some screening companies say their lab-developed tests aren't subject to FDA regulation.

The Journal.
Fertility Inc.: The Embryo Editing Dinner

I definitely get the concerns, but...

The Journal.
Fertility Inc.: The Embryo Editing Dinner

As a parent who wants what's best for your kids, I can see how this can be really alluring.

The Journal.
Fertility Inc.: The Embryo Editing Dinner

But the question, though, is where do you draw the line?

The Journal.
Fertility Inc.: The Embryo Editing Dinner

And there's just so much morality tied up in that.

The Journal.
Fertility Inc.: The Embryo Editing Dinner

It also seems in a lot of ways that this story is like a case study in how the medical community in Silicon Valley just approach problems very differently.