Menu
Sign In Search Podcasts Charts People & Topics Add Podcast API Blog Pricing

Samuel Tongue

๐Ÿ‘ค Speaker
551 total appearances

Appearances Over Time

Podcast Appearances

Scottish Poetry Library Podcast
Nothing But The Poem - Jack Gilbert

I'm not sure about the image of the gentleness in her like antelope standing in the dawn mist.

Scottish Poetry Library Podcast
Nothing But The Poem - Jack Gilbert

That didn't strike me as a fabulously well constructed image, but that was just me.

Scottish Poetry Library Podcast
Nothing But The Poem - Jack Gilbert

But within the flow of the poem and the kind of flow of images, it does fit.

Scottish Poetry Library Podcast
Nothing But The Poem - Jack Gilbert

It does fit there.

Scottish Poetry Library Podcast
Nothing But The Poem - Jack Gilbert

Whenever we're discussing these poems as a group, I like to emphasize that you can dislike the poem, of course, and you can dislike

Scottish Poetry Library Podcast
Nothing But The Poem - Jack Gilbert

lines and you can suggest edits and you can as long as they're justifiable i think that's a really important part of creating an interpretation i'm working through why those words and those phrases and those images and those metaphors are there what is the poet doing with them do you think and i think that's so that kind of critical voice does not does not kill a poem i think it's an in an engagement with part of the dance part of the dance with a poem

Scottish Poetry Library Podcast
Nothing But The Poem - Jack Gilbert

Yeah, coming to that, it feels like the poem is very much centered on marriage, on a relationship that is kind of folding and fading.

Scottish Poetry Library Podcast
Nothing But The Poem - Jack Gilbert

But again, that's not necessarily to devalue it.

Scottish Poetry Library Podcast
Nothing But The Poem - Jack Gilbert

The whole poem seems to be about revaluing or valuing.

Scottish Poetry Library Podcast
Nothing But The Poem - Jack Gilbert

things as they disappear or as they fade, that feels like a very contemporary tone and conclusion.

Scottish Poetry Library Podcast
Nothing But The Poem - Jack Gilbert

Things fading, things falling apart, but that doesn't necessarily mean they need to be devalued or they are devalued.

Scottish Poetry Library Podcast
Nothing But The Poem - Jack Gilbert

And that certainly comes across in that final two lines where the poet says, I believe Icarus was not failing as he fell, but just coming to the end of his triumph, which anything that can be described as a triumph cannot be described as a failure.

Scottish Poetry Library Podcast
Nothing But The Poem - Jack Gilbert

It was only a few pages on, but, and this is also part of

Scottish Poetry Library Podcast
Nothing But The Poem - Jack Gilbert

Yes, quite a lot of the time I tend to select individual poems, but this time I actually selected poems from the same collection.

Scottish Poetry Library Podcast
Nothing But The Poem - Jack Gilbert

Obviously poems exist as individual poems, often solo, often published in journals and in the wider world before they appear in a collection.

Scottish Poetry Library Podcast
Nothing But The Poem - Jack Gilbert

But I love how, and I think it's important to investigate how poems work as part of a collection.

Scottish Poetry Library Podcast
Nothing But The Poem - Jack Gilbert

And what happens when you read from left to right, traditionally in a book, you don't have to.

Scottish Poetry Library Podcast
Nothing But The Poem - Jack Gilbert

Maybe, I mean, some people start from the back.

Scottish Poetry Library Podcast
Nothing But The Poem - Jack Gilbert

Some people grab a poem whose title really speaks to them.

Scottish Poetry Library Podcast
Nothing But The Poem - Jack Gilbert

But I think in the main, editors and publishers tend to think you're going to read a collection from left to right, from beginning to middle to end.