Shiel Kapadia

What do you think?

It's boom or bust.

It's high variance.

It's interesting.

It absolutely is interesting.

More so than hiring, you know, kind of one of those veteran OCs who are like, wait a minute, it's Matt Nagy.

He's the guy who's going to elevate this offense in 2026.

So I like the risk that they're taking here.

The ways you outlined in which it goes wrong, you hit the nail on the head.

I mean, first of all, we have no idea if he can do the job or not.

He has not done it.

He has not called plays.

He has not schemed up an offense on his own.

He's completely unproven.

And I think the Eagles went into this process hoping to get someone who was proven, who they could say, this guy has a resume.

He's going to come in.

He's done it before.

But once those guys were off the table, the Mike McDaniel, the Todd Munkin, whoever else that maybe they had on their list initially, now you had to decide, do we want to go with someone who's done it before, but might not have been great doing it?

Or do we want to just take a risk on someone?

And so I applaud, you know, I do applaud them for saying, let's take a risk.