Menu
Sign In Search Podcasts Charts People & Topics Add Podcast API Blog Pricing

Steven Zuber

๐Ÿ‘ค Speaker
1466 total appearances

Appearances Over Time

Podcast Appearances

The Bayesian Conspiracy
254 โ€“ The True Theme and Meaning of HPMOR

But I would say Harry's and rationalists as a whole desire to want to understand things and...

The Bayesian Conspiracy
254 โ€“ The True Theme and Meaning of HPMOR

not be afraid of the truth is the other major core like i i it's weird to say something can have two cores but um because those two things don't really tie together unless i really squint uh one's heroic responsibility and one's dedication to the truth but i mean i guess you can't can't really be responsible if you're lying to yourself maybe and i

The Bayesian Conspiracy
254 โ€“ The True Theme and Meaning of HPMOR

Yeah, I was going to say to successfully interact in it.

The Bayesian Conspiracy
254 โ€“ The True Theme and Meaning of HPMOR

For sure.

The Bayesian Conspiracy
254 โ€“ The True Theme and Meaning of HPMOR

Yeah, no, I love it.

The Bayesian Conspiracy
254 โ€“ The True Theme and Meaning of HPMOR

But there's at least one other major moral or major other plot or thrust of the story, right?

The Bayesian Conspiracy
254 โ€“ The True Theme and Meaning of HPMOR

Yeah, absolutely.

The Bayesian Conspiracy
254 โ€“ The True Theme and Meaning of HPMOR

And it's beautifully done.

The Bayesian Conspiracy
254 โ€“ The True Theme and Meaning of HPMOR

And Hermione is, as far as Death of the Author goes, Yudkowsky called her a Mary Sue, which is derisive.

The Bayesian Conspiracy
254 โ€“ The True Theme and Meaning of HPMOR

But I don't think that she's unrealistically good.

The Bayesian Conspiracy
254 โ€“ The True Theme and Meaning of HPMOR

There are people who can be Hermione Grangers.

The Bayesian Conspiracy
254 โ€“ The True Theme and Meaning of HPMOR

And

The Bayesian Conspiracy
254 โ€“ The True Theme and Meaning of HPMOR

So, you know, if she's a Mary Sue and how quickly she learns magic or whatever, fine.

The Bayesian Conspiracy
254 โ€“ The True Theme and Meaning of HPMOR

But she's not an impossibly good person any more than Voldemort's an impossibly bad one.

The Bayesian Conspiracy
254 โ€“ The True Theme and Meaning of HPMOR

that's what it takes that's that's her death star or her lightsaber whichever whichever side she is uh in order to keep the two sides in check so that there can be an actual battle for harry soul i like that yeah i i remember that quote and i took it to mean that you can't make harry smarter without making the enemy smarter because otherwise it'd be very boring story like that one outtake that it had where after like first whatever their first breakfast he goes to dumbledore's office and explains yeah i noticed that it hurts when i look at the back of professor quarrel's head

The Bayesian Conspiracy
254 โ€“ The True Theme and Meaning of HPMOR

But I guess this is not related to the post, but I have an interpretation of it question for you.

The Bayesian Conspiracy
254 โ€“ The True Theme and Meaning of HPMOR

So Quirrell assumes that Harry will be aligned with him immediately, right?

The Bayesian Conspiracy
254 โ€“ The True Theme and Meaning of HPMOR

Do you think it's because, well, of course you can't be smart and good because I'm smart and good people are morons is what Quirrell's thinking.

The Bayesian Conspiracy
254 โ€“ The True Theme and Meaning of HPMOR

Or is he thinking, of course he's aligned with me.

The Bayesian Conspiracy
254 โ€“ The True Theme and Meaning of HPMOR

I imprinted my brain on his infant brain.