This man had the cleanest record in the entire school district—and that was the problem.In 1982, a quiet janitor named Martin Hale worked at Brookside Elementary. He was the kind of employee every principal wanted to keep. He arrived before sunrise, sweeping the halls and unlocking classrooms. He stayed late, polishing floors until they shone. Teachers described him as polite and soft-spoken. Students knew his humming—the same gentle tune echoing through the building as he locked doors at night.If a child lost a backpack, Martin found it. If a teacher needed help, Martin appeared before they even asked. On paper, his record was spotless.Then someone noticed a pattern.Every building Martin Hale worked in had something in common: a student went missing. A second grader walking home. A shy girl from the music club. A boy who stayed late for tutoring. Each case was investigated on its own. None of them were connected to each other—or to the janitor sweeping the floors.That changed one night when a substitute teacher realized she’d left her purse in a classroom and returned to the school after dark. The building was silent. As she passed the cafeteria, she heard humming—Martin’s tune—coming from somewhere below.She found a service door she’d never noticed, leading to a narrow staircase. At the bottom was a concrete hallway just wide enough for one person to walk through. A single bulb flickered overhead. On both walls, in neat rows, were small brass nameplates. Each one bore the name of a child who had gone missing from the schools where Martin had worked.Martin stepped out of the shadows and smiled. Then, in a voice barely above a whisper, he told her:“I never leave a mess behind. Not even them.”

Ask this episode

“What did the council decide on item 42?” — answered with the speaker and the moment.

Transcript

Related