He was the Justin Bieber of the 1930s—then the story swerved. In 1933, singer Harry Footman rocketed to fame. Four years later came Guilty as Charged, an album whose tracks were all people’s names. Listeners said the lyrics felt like threats. They called the police.The legend claims that in Harry’s hometown, a run of missing-person reports from the previous year matched the tracklist. There’s even an impossible date printed on some sleeves—“October 32, 1937”—a cursed detail collectors still whisper about.Authorities moved to arrest him onstage. He bolted, a hundred-car chase behind him. After three hours, the car rolled to a stop—no driver, just a brick on the gas pedal. Harry Footman was never seen again. As the years went on, the music didn’t vanish; people say versions still circulate online, though the provenance shifts with each retelling.This episode critiques the folklore versus the record: the “confession album” trope, how a fanbase can become a manhunt, and why an absurd date can feel more truthful than a clean timeline. No verdicts—just a needle tapping against paper and a crowd waiting for an encore that never came.

Ask this episode

“What did the council decide on item 42?” — answered with the speaker and the moment.

Transcript

Related