Menu
Sign In Search Podcasts Libraries Charts People & Topics Add Podcast API Blog Pricing
Podcast Image

Page 94: The Private Eye Podcast

175: PAUL FOOT 2026: CUTTING CORNERS

25 May 2026

Transcription

Transcript generated automatically by AI and may contain errors.

Chapter 1: What is the main topic discussed in this episode?

2.09 - 24.899 Unknown

During Memorial Day at Lowe's, shop household must-haves for less. Save $80 on a Char-Broil Performance Series 4-burner grill to chef up something special. Plus, get up to 45% off select major appliances to keep things fresh. Our best lineup is here at Lowe's. Lowe's. We help. You save. Valid through 527. While supplies last. Selection varies by location. See Lowe's.com for details.

0

25.16 - 29.245 Unknown

Visit your nearby Lowe's on Russell Branch Parkway southeast in Leesburg.

0

30.085 - 48.464 Andrew Hunter-Murray

Hello and welcome to Page 94. My name is Andrew Hunter-Murray and I'm here in the Private Eye offices about to interview the shortlist for this year's Paul Foot Award in memory of the late, great campaigning investigative journalist Paul Foot. So let's see which is the first of the stories to be shortlisted for this year's award.

0

48.904 - 51.507 Unknown

Page 94, the Private Eye podcast.

0

52.128 - 57.618 Andrew Hunter-Murray

Joe Duggan, reporter for the iPaper. Joe, what's the story that's brought you to the Pulford Award this year?

58.159 - 71.972 Joe Duggan

Since 2024, we've been reporting on cases of silicosis in young workers cutting a stone known as quartz or engineered stone, which is a stone that's become very popular in makeovers for people who are doing their kitchens up. So...

71.952 - 82.669 Andrew Hunter-Murray

The basic headline seems to be fashionable kitchen work tops can actually be leading to serious illness or even death among the workers who are cutting it.

82.93 - 102.5 Joe Duggan

Yeah, and we don't yet know the scale of the problem in this country, but it's the most popular stone for people having kitchens and everyone's got a kitchen. So we know of more than 50 cases so far, but it's likely to be significantly higher than that. Somebody I know works in the industry and contacted me and said, you know, have you heard of this stuff, engineered stone quartz?

102.52 - 110.391 Joe Duggan

You know, he was refusing to work with it. He said it's too dangerous. I don't want to put my workers at risk. They've just banned it in Australia. What's the situation here? Yeah.

Chapter 2: What is the story behind silicosis in young workers?

110.752 - 122.428 Joe Duggan

I'd never heard of it. I didn't know what it was. I knew what silicosis was. It's an occupational lung disease, which sort of historically has always been, you know, people are working in mining, construction industry.

0

122.408 - 144.99 Joe Duggan

um have developed silicosis usually after quite a number of years of exposure to dust from cutting stone what we found with the cases of silicosis in the guys who were cutting these kitchen workshops is they were starting to develop it very young and after not very long exposure off you know a couple two or three years in some cases yeah

0

144.97 - 155.149 Joe Duggan

So they were getting ill and dying younger than historically workers have done when they've contracted silicosis from cutting stone.

0

155.382 - 161.329 Andrew Hunter-Murray

What is the substance that you referred to at the top there? Did you say engineered quartz? Engineered stone, yeah.

0

161.449 - 184.174 Joe Duggan

It's also known as quartz, and it's become the most popular stone that people have installed in their kitchens when they want a new worktop. It's cheaper than granite and marble, but it looks attractive as well. Is it a composite? Yeah, it's man-made. It's a man-made stone. It has a very high level of silica in it. Cutting silica

184.154 - 208.001 Joe Duggan

exposes workers who aren't using who aren't being provided with proper safety protection to dust and the higher the silica level the higher the risk to the worker who's cutting it and in case in the case of quartz it can be very high 95 percent silica content whereas granite and marble for example i think the numbers for either are like 30 percent much less Can I check?

208.021 - 209.563 Andrew Hunter-Murray

This is workers in the UK.

210.364 - 233.114 Joe Duggan

So how we started to get involved in the story was my friend asked me, what's the situation here? And I really didn't know where to start. So I just looked up all the top respiratory consultants in the UK who deal with occupational lung disease and just started ringing them up to find out, are there any cases of silicosis here? from quartz.

233.495 - 250.675 Joe Duggan

And eventually that led me to Dr. Jo Feery, who's a doctor at the Royal Brompton Hospital, who is the main doctor looking after the UK's first quartz silicosis patients. So she told me in January 2024, yes, we have started to see the first cases. They've developed in the last few months.

Chapter 3: How does engineered stone contribute to health risks?

280.747 - 292.625 Andrew Hunter-Murray

So am I right in understanding that there are precautionary measures you can take, there are protective masks, there are things that you can do to mitigate the risk of silica and of silicosis?

0

292.885 - 305.725 Joe Duggan

The main one is, they call it wet cutting, which is using water suppressing tools to stop the dust from developing. What we found is the profile of the guys who, and it is all men who are getting it,

0

305.705 - 323.477 Joe Duggan

who are getting silicosis they're working for firms who are just not following these safety rules and just leaving them exposed they tend to say as i say they tend to be very very young um a lot of them are migrant workers who are just being exploited basically

0

323.457 - 328.164 Andrew Hunter-Murray

Because it's slightly more expensive to use the wet cutting method that makes it a lot safer.

0

328.304 - 334.614 Joe Duggan

Yeah, the firms that they're working for are just cutting corners and not providing their workers with the correct tools.

334.895 - 341.044 Andrew Hunter-Murray

Do you know roughly how many people are working in this industry or who might be exposed to this?

341.024 - 369.575 Joe Duggan

It's been difficult to get sort of figures on it, but there's been a bit of analysis done recently. And that analysis has estimated there's around 7,000 workers working in the industry. We're working on a story based on that analysis at the minute this week. So the latest figures so far are that there are diagnosed 55 workers with silicosis since mid-2023. At least four have died.

369.615 - 380.329 Joe Duggan

But the doctors do believe that there's probably a significant number more that are out there that haven't been diagnosed yet. Who is meant to be regulating this? The Health and Safety Executive.

380.562 - 386.23 Andrew Hunter-Murray

Okay. And I imagine that fairly early on in reporting the story, you asked them about it.

Comments

There are no comments yet.

Please log in to write the first comment.