Menu
Sign In Search Podcasts Charts People & Topics Add Podcast API Blog Pricing
Podcast Image

The Bulwark Podcast

Amanda Carpenter: Let the Media Dinosaurs Die

27 Feb 2026

Transcription

Chapter 1: How does Amanda Carpenter view the current media landscape?

13.075 - 27.348 Tim Miller

Hello and welcome to the Bulwark Podcast. I'm your host, Tim Miller. It is Friday. Delighted to welcome back our former friend. She's now a writer and editor at projectdemocracy.org, which is pretty important. And this week she was a guest host on The View. It's all caps, Amanda Carpenter. What's up, Amanda?

0

27.648 - 29.312 Amanda Carpenter

Wait, hold on. Former friend?

0

30.524 - 32.286 Tim Miller

Well, is that what I said?

0

32.486 - 40.015 Amanda Carpenter

You said former friend. Wow, that's a demotion. Like, you guys have best friends, you have all kinds of things, and I'm former friend.

0

40.035 - 42.438 Tim Miller

Current friend, former colleague.

Chapter 2: What insights does Amanda Carpenter share about her experience on The View?

43.099 - 53.612 Tim Miller

Close ally. Partner in crime. Whatever you want to say. You were on The View this week. Can I indulge you for a second in the audience with something? You were replacing Alyssa Farah.

0

53.932 - 58.978 Amanda Carpenter

I was filling in. Let's be clear. I was a guest for three days. But yeah, it's your show, dude.

0

59.06 - 71.858 Tim Miller

You're filling in for Alyssa Farah. Had a new baby, Justin. Congrats to her. And Alyssa, you know, look, Alyssa worked for Mike Pence. Alyssa was in there in Trump 1.0.

0

Chapter 3: Why is Trump’s influence significant in today's media mergers?

72.839 - 88.835 Tim Miller

So fair skepticism about Alyssa sometimes from people. And let me tell you, that fair skepticism extended to me. When I was writing Why We Did It, I was trying to analyze the psychology of people who knew better but went along with Trump anyway.

0

88.855 - 105.942 Tim Miller

So it's kind of hard to pick representative people because I didn't want to do a Mean Girls Burn book, you know, where I was just like slaying random people and like just choosing based on like past slights from campaigns of yore. And so what I decided to do was choose the group that did the autopsy with me.

0

105.922 - 127.72 Tim Miller

Because me and one other woman were basically the only people that didn't go along with Trump, the core autopsy group. But the problem was like none of those people like really fit one archetype. And so I needed somebody else to offer to participate. And I called around to different people. And I didn't know this at all. I'd never met her. And we met in secret. It was very furtive.

0

127.88 - 129.464 Tim Miller

You know, she was nervous. Like an ally?

0

Chapter 4: How are independent outlets like The Bulwark changing the media space?

129.644 - 139.628 Tim Miller

You don't want to be seen with me. With you? She didn't want to be seen with you? She didn't want to be seen with me. Well, right, because, you know, she's still in a transition period, right? When was this? This was like right after she had quit.

0

139.929 - 140.029 Unknown

Okay.

0

140.009 - 151.346 Tim Miller

It was right after January 6th. She was like, do I still want to work in Republican politics? Do I just want to burn it down? Do I want to go be a shepherd? She didn't know.

0

151.387 - 151.987 Amanda Carpenter

She's going through it.

0

152.448 - 154.071 Tim Miller

We're keeping optionality.

Chapter 5: What challenges do states face in combating ICE and election meddling?

154.591 - 179.17 Tim Miller

Meeting in a random hotel in secret. We start talking. We vibed out. We both had the Lebanese thing going. My impression of her was that... Initially, was that like, maybe she got over her skis. It's kind of fake. I don't know. Anyway, I started interviewing her. We met once. We met twice. We met a third time. Go to her house in Georgetown. And we went for hours.

0

179.771 - 181.293 Tim Miller

And we're just talking, drinking wine.

0

Chapter 6: What are the implications of DHS's surveillance practices?

181.333 - 196.814 Tim Miller

And the thing we kept going back and forth on, which was like the whole point of the book, was like, why did you go in and why did you quit? Those are the questions we're trying to answer. Why did you really do it? Not like the lip service reason that you said. At a deep level, why did you do it?

0

196.834 - 197.835 Amanda Carpenter

So you got her all liquored up.

0

197.855 - 221.401 Tim Miller

So we got her all liquored up, right. And at the time, she doesn't have a kid. And they're trying to have a kid, but they're struggling to get through the whole IVF thing. She's talked about this. And... She just gets very emotional and starts talking about her dad had just had a stroke and her dad was like a MAGA. A pre-MAGA, a proto-MAGA media.

0

221.602 - 224.565 Amanda Carpenter

Well, was it World Net Daily? It was one of the wild ones.

0

Chapter 7: How do personal experiences shape political beliefs and actions?

224.585 - 232.034 Amanda Carpenter

And of all the ones, you know, I worked at human events. That was wild for me. Like they were all in on the birther stuff, as I recall.

0

232.215 - 234.578 Tim Miller

Yeah, correct. So her dad was really out there.

0

234.598 - 235.539 Amanda Carpenter

Yeah, big time.

0

235.979 - 248.257 Tim Miller

And she starts to get kind of, he just had a stroke. It starts to get emotional. She says this to me. She was like, since that I've been thinking about mortality and legacy and marrying into a family where I'm so proud of who they are. thinking about my dad and what he could have been.

0

248.277 - 264.308 Tim Miller

I don't care about money or different things, but I want my kids and grandkids to look back and be like, she was someone who did the right thing. I don't need anyone to pat me on the back. I just want my kids to remember me the right way. And at the time, I was like, wow.

Chapter 8: What future trends do Amanda and Tim see in media and politics?

264.549 - 272.483 Tim Miller

We were both a little drunk, so I was getting a little emotional. But at the time, I was like, hmm. You don't even have a kid. That's one thing to say if you have a teenager.

0

272.503 - 276.987 Amanda Carpenter

Well, women tend to think about this. What? Right? No, I mean, she knew she wanted to have a kid the next couple years, though.

0

277.007 - 279.489 Tim Miller

She knew she wanted to have a kid. But, like, that is crazy.

0

279.509 - 280.49 Amanda Carpenter

This is what women think about.

0

281.01 - 298.266 Tim Miller

Yeah, it's what women think about. Yeah, so the men are from Mars, women from Venus thing. This goes back to Charles Duhigg, emotional conversation versus practical. But I just was thinking about that for her this week. And I was just like, she wanted to have this kid so bad. And this, like, the specter of this, the prospect of this, and wanting to be a good parent.

298.246 - 315.713 Tim Miller

like weighed on her and that resonated with me at such a level because like it's something that I kept coming back to a lot after January 6th and this time which is like You people know your kids are going to go to school someday and like they're not going to care about your spin, right?

315.753 - 336.484 Tim Miller

Like they're going to be in high school and there's going to be a picture of people storming the Capitol with Confederate flags and Trump flags. And it's going to be two paragraphs in the chapter. And it's going to be like Donald Trump tried to overturn the democracy. They stormed the Capitol. Police officers died. That's what your kids are going to learn.

336.884 - 353.406 Tim Miller

And they're not going to care that you said, well, you know, the Democrats, they woke, got a little out of control, you know, and I, and I bring that up to people all the time. And most of them, you know, humming, humming, humming it. And she cared about it at a deep level. So anyway, I just, I love this for her. I'm happy.

353.446 - 360.535 Tim Miller

She, she's on a little maternity leave and you know, we all make choices in life, but that's something else to be a good mom.

Comments

There are no comments yet.

Please log in to write the first comment.