Menu
Sign In Search Podcasts Libraries Charts People & Topics Add Podcast API Blog Pricing
Podcast Image

The Prancing Pony Podcast

410 – You Got Lucky, Gollum

26 Apr 2026

Transcription

Transcript generated automatically by AI and may contain errors.

Chapter 1: What is discussed at the start of this section?

0.436 - 34.966 Alan Sisto

Do you ever wish you could step away from the noise of the world for a From the inn on the lake to the downtown bookshop, from the farmer's market to a cabin in the woods, you'll hear warm, family-friendly stories designed to help you slow down, breathe easier, and feel at home. It's sort of like easy listening, but for fiction.

0

35.728 - 60.181 Alan Sisto

It's a bit like a grown-up version of Mr. Rogers' Neighborhood, gentle, thoughtful, and full of everyday magic. It's from the creator of the internationally beloved podcast, Nothing Much Happens, and the series expands the village into a rich, ongoing world. It isn't about falling asleep. It's about comfort, calm, and the joy of a good story. If you're new, try episode 84.

0

60.721 - 73.162 Alan Sisto

It's called All Animal Edition, and it is a delightful introduction to the village's quiet pace and fun whimsy. You can listen to Stories from the Village of Nothing Much wherever you get your podcasts.

0

75.786 - 98.703 Unknown

Learning English is hard. That's why I make easy stories in English, where you can have fun while you learn. You can listen to stories full of action, romance, and mystery. Each episode, I tell stories for beginner, intermediate and advanced learners, and there's a story for every mood.

0

98.803 - 107.224 Unknown

Whether you want something to wake you up or relax before going to bed, Easy Stories in English is the podcast for you.

118.612 - 127.305 Alan Sisto

Good evening, little masters, and welcome to episode 410 of the Prancing Pony podcast, where no doubt more could have been wrung from Matt by torture.

128.106 - 145.833 Matt

You're still not going to know what a Baggins is. I'll put it that way. All right. You're not going to know. No. Folks, pull up a bench in the common room and join us. I'm Matt, the Nerd of the Rings, and I'm here with the man of the West who made a very small and natural heir, Alan Sisto. You mean inviting you back?

146.374 - 155.188 Alan Sisto

Probably, yeah. Folks, join us as we get a closer look at Aragorn's unpleasant journey as we continue our four-part look at the hunt for the ring from Unfinished Tales.

155.588 - 174.859 Matt

Folks, no matter whether you came to Middle-Earth through the books, the films, the TV show, or something else, each of you is welcome here in our common room. The Prancing Pony podcast continues in our 10th season of reading and talking our way through Middle-Earth with conversations, digressions, and even speculations.

Chapter 2: What insights do we gain about Gollum and Sauron's relationship?

337.629 - 350.705 Matt

Like I got to play it. I had never played it before, played it on the big fancy table. Oh yeah. It's got some great strategy that, that works in the elements of the story and the characters.

0

351.066 - 357.514 Unknown

I'm going to need a bigger studio rings. Yeah.

0

357.494 - 366.213 Alan Sisto

That sounds like a good one. That must have been fun. Your interviews are always intriguing, and I'm glad that you get a chance to talk to some of these incredible folks.

0

366.534 - 372.006 Matt

Yeah. And it was fun because it was up in Minnesota, so I got to check another ballpark off my list. I went to a Twins game.

0

372.026 - 392.08 Alan Sisto

You got to go to the Twin Cities. Yeah. Right on. Well, one other thing, speaking of baseball, when you're on the show with me, people expect a few more sports references and maybe a few less Babylon 5 or 80s music references. You've been branching out a bit, right? You're not just the nerd of the rings anymore. You're the nerd of the diamond, the nerd of the hardwood, even the nerd of the ice.

393.262 - 398.571 Alan Sisto

Talk to me about some of your sports stuff with a brief apology to our non-sport viewing listeners.

398.669 - 412.63 Matt

Yeah, so I love the nerd of the diamond hardwood and ice there. Yeah, people who follow me on Twitter or Instagram will notice I occasionally post about my sports teams.

413.031 - 416.777 Alan Sisto

Usually it's gripes about refereeing during a Pacers game from what I've noticed.

416.797 - 421.724 Matt

Oh my gosh, don't even get me started on the finals. Don't even get me started on the finals.

Chapter 3: How does the discussion shift to the characters' journeys?

542.352 - 546.578 Matt

I've always been a big fan.

0

546.598 - 554.629 Alan Sisto

Oh, that would be great. Yeah. That's good. That's got a good rhythm to it too. Yeah. Watch him coming out to that music. I wouldn't want to bat against that.

0

555.309 - 568.504 Matt

Did you, did you catch, I know like we're, we're totally, we're, we're crossing over though. This is Lord of the Rings related at this point. So during the national championship game where IU beats Miami, I think it was.

0

568.524 - 569.345 Alan Sisto

Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.

0

569.365 - 574.451 Matt

Yeah. The, the IU band was playing the Isengard theme. They were playing a ton of Lord of the Rings stuff.

574.491 - 578.896 Alan Sisto

I think they were playing at least two or three different themes, but yeah, the Isengard theme kept popping up a lot.

579.116 - 579.396 Matt

Yeah.

579.716 - 582.019 Alan Sisto

Which is a great, great sound for a band. Yeah.

581.999 - 601.857 Matt

Another fun fact in that same, I'm just all over the place because I'm getting really excited of this crossover. I am too, actually. Last time I was at a Cubs game at Wrigley Field, which has been a few years ago now, I actually tweeted at the organist for the Cubs, like you should play some Lord of the Rings music.

Chapter 4: What are the key themes in the lore of Middle-Earth explored here?

650.48 - 658.328 Alan Sisto

I was watching that game with rapt attention. But yeah, I remember thinking, that's so cool that we get Lord of the Rings music while we're watching the national championship game.

0

658.308 - 662.534 Matt

That is, yeah. Maybe he'll ask for it at the Raiders games.

0

663.075 - 683.725 Alan Sisto

There you go. You never know. Well, we're now done with the sports questions. Yeah, let's get it. Sorry. You can come back now. Come on back. All right. Matt, you and I have chatted about adaptations a lot over the years. And I don't just mean Rings of Power. I mean, we have obviously talked about that. But we've talked about War of the Rohirrim. We've talked about video game adaptations.

0

683.705 - 699.03 Alan Sisto

But let's talk a bit more. Or rather, you talk, I listen, because it's an interview. What is the one thing that you're most looking forward to for season three of The Rings of Power? And after you've answered that hard question, the easy one is what's the one thing you're most worried about?

0

699.28 - 715.522 Matt

Okay, so I would say a couple things that I'm looking forward to. One, I think that by necessity, Elendil will have a bigger role going forward. Oh, he's got to, doesn't he?

715.903 - 718.386 Alan Sisto

Whether that'll be season four or not, though, I don't know.

718.703 - 727.395 Matt

Yeah, I'm not 100% sure, but I mean, so the older Durin was killed off. Celebrimbor is killed off.

727.816 - 728.076 Unknown

Yep.

728.497 - 759.595 Matt

Adar is killed off. So like three of the characters that were a fairly big focus of season two- are now gone so that's screen time that's available and I think I think Elendil is one that like I hope so and Gil-galad for that matter oh yeah the two of them need a lot more in the next two seasons before the final showdown with Sauron like that's mm-hmm

Chapter 5: What new details are revealed about the Nazgûl's weaknesses?

3223.817 - 3237.423 Alan Sisto

So yeah, it's still, I still always say, but are you sure? Yeah. Well, let's go ahead and look at the cons because this is where we get a lot more detail in this version than we did in last week's.

0

3237.443 - 3251.285 Alan Sisto

I mean, sure, in manuscript A last week, we saw that so great was the terror that went with them, even invisible and unclad, that their coming forth might soon be perceived in their mission guessed by the wise. So already not exactly stealthy, right, Matt?

0

3251.305 - 3252.006 Matt

Right. Yeah.

0
0

3252.367 - 3271.791 Matt

here we're told something quite similar but it's even stronger because now we're told it's not just that the terror is great even when invisible and unclad the terror is actually greater in that case that's interesting yeah And it's also more amplified when they're all together.

3272.453 - 3282.882 Alan Sisto

So it's not even invisible. Like, oh, well, maybe they're not quite as scary. No, they're still pretty scary. It's that they're even more scary. Even more. So it's quite unstealthy.

3283.725 - 3283.825 Unknown

Yes.

3283.805 - 3288.49 Alan Sisto

Really, this is not what you use if you're trying to be secretive about what you're doing.

Chapter 6: Why are the Nazgûl afraid of water?

3288.891 - 3302.206 Alan Sisto

But the new information is what's interesting. And there are two bits in particular, though I should say right up front that neither of these drawbacks apply to the Witch King. He is just that good. That's right. He is the Witch King.

0

3302.747 - 3319.959 Matt

He is. The first is that unless they're all together, they're likely to wander off during the daytime. which is funny in and of itself is like their dogs, their dogs coming across squirrels or something. They just start wandering off.

0

3320.8 - 3334.58 Matt

Like you got to put them on a leash, but recall last week, the footnote that we read saying that Kamul was the one whose power was most confused and diminished by daylight.

0

3334.6 - 3351.502 Alan Sisto

Oh, and I do love this idea, but the second and actually more problematic concern is is that they're all terrified of water. So much so that except in dire need, and boy, do I want to know exactly what that means, they won't cross rivers except on a bridge.

0

3351.982 - 3377.7 Alan Sisto

The footnote here reminding us that only the Witch King and two others with the lure of the ring straight before them had dared to enter the river, talking about at the Grey Flood when they were going after Frodo. The rest were driven into the river by Glorfindel and Aragorn. Why are they afraid of water? What in the world? Right? What is the deal here? What do you think it is?

3378.288 - 3393.585 Matt

No, like I honestly don't know. I just immediately think when they do go after Frodo though, and the waters come rushing in, I'm like, it's like putting an arachnophobe in a room of spiders, you know?

3393.685 - 3396.628 Alan Sisto

I'm thinking Indiana Jones snakes. Why did it have to be snakes?

3396.688 - 3401.554 Matt

Yes. Like that did nothing to help that fear for sure.

3401.954 - 3403.095 Alan Sisto

Now it's baked in.

Chapter 7: How does Sauron react to Gollum's capture?

0

3405.727 - 3424.43 Alan Sisto

And maybe the ring was the thing that constituted dire need and drove two of them to follow. But I wonder what else would constitute dire need because you don't think of the Witch King as the kind of like a nice boss who is going to give you, you know, your vacation that you request, you know, every time. This is not a guy you want to work for.

0

3424.49 - 3428.575 Alan Sisto

And so I think dire need is anytime he tells you you have a dire need.

0

3428.595 - 3430.097 Unknown

Anytime he says yes.

0

3431.14 - 3441.161 Alan Sisto

I don't care if you're afraid of the water. Of course, this whole time I'm, I'm thinking of them being afraid of the water. I'm thinking of the aliens from signs. Did you see signs?

3441.242 - 3441.522 Matt

Yes.

3441.783 - 3449.717 Alan Sisto

Oh yes, of course. Yeah. So it's like a, Swing away, Merrill. That's right. The Nazgul afraid of water.

Chapter 8: What changes in Sauron's strategy are discussed?

3449.737 - 3459.052 Matt

Actually, I recently showed that movie to my kids and I won't. Oh, great movie. Yeah. I won't tell you what grade I was in when that movie came out. Oh, shush.

0

3459.553 - 3461.957 Alan Sisto

Grade? You were in a grade?

0

3464.131 - 3487.864 Matt

Wow, that hurts. On that note, at the end of all this, Sauron has to weigh two factors in using the ringwraiths. The inability for them to do this secretly, because everyone's going to know it's them, and the logistical problems about crossing the giant river that lies between them and the direction of the Shire.

0
0

3489.95 - 3493.414 Alan Sisto

Not to mention all the other smaller rivers, but especially the Anduin.

3493.935 - 3502.987 Matt

Yes, the Anduin. And these concerns gave Sauron enough pause that he waited a long time before dispatching the ringwraiths.

3503.307 - 3527.136 Alan Sisto

Yeah. We also learned that Sauron would not have believed that anyone other than Gollum and whoever, whatever Baggins was, would know about the ring. And this is interesting. We're even told Gollum didn't know who Gandalf was. Don't you know who I am? He's famous. Come on. That's right. Or that he was connected with Bilbo until after Gandalf questioned him in Thranduil's halls.

3528.037 - 3552.423 Alan Sisto

The footnote reminding us, of course, that he spoke of questioning Gollum during the Council of Elrond. So interesting. So Sauron thinks the existence of the ring is that secret, but why would Gollum and Baggins necessarily keep that knowledge to themselves? Like what... Yeah. Is he counting on the terrifying nature of the ring or like the beneficial invisibility?

3553.105 - 3558.178 Alan Sisto

Is he counting on that being the reason why these mortal ring bearers wouldn't tell anyone?

Comments

There are no comments yet.

Please log in to write the first comment.