Menu
Sign In Search Podcasts Libraries Charts People & Topics Add Podcast API Blog Pricing
Podcast Image

Uncanny

Cold Cases: Case 12: Borley Rectory Part 2

23 Jun 2026

Transcription

Transcript generated automatically by AI and may contain errors.

Chapter 1: What is the main topic discussed in this episode?

0.031 - 25.866

This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK. Lounasjahti on katettu nesteliikenneasemille. Käytä plussakorttiasi nesteliikenneasemilla ja voit voittaa kuukauden lounaat. Tankkaa lounasta, osta vaikka jätski. Kunhan mustat käyttää plussakorttia toinen elokuuta asti, olet mukana jahdissa. Nappaa mukaan samalla kesäkuun plussaedut. Lisätiedot neste.fi kautta plussa.

0

26.146 - 35.86

Tuli pulkkamäkiä, polttareita tai puutarhajuhlia. Löydät nyt yli tuhat pysyvästi edullista tuotetta K-ruokakaupoista.

0

39.637 - 63.139 Danny Robbins

Hello and welcome back to The Most Haunted House in England. Last time we opened the doors to Borley Rectory, we heard about how successive inhabitants of the house had been plagued by unearthly noises, poltergeist activity, ghostly carriages travelling up the drive and a phantom nun stalking the gardens. Who are you going to call?

0

63.219 - 88.408 Danny Robbins

Well, we know back in 1929, it was Harry Price, the preeminent Ghostbuster of his age. His first visit to the house was an unforgettable experience. Remember, he and a journalist came under attack from invisible assailants, seeing the ghost nun as well, and also apparently communicating with the former owner of the house, Harry Bull, who claimed to have been murdered by his wife, Ivy.

0

88.388 - 119.509 Danny Robbins

It is, as they say, a lot. So hold on tight, because we've got a shed load to investigate already and plenty more to come. Welcome back to Bawley Rectory. I'm Danny Robbins, and this is Uncanny Cold Cases. But still

136.516 - 162.675 Danny Robbins

Hello, I am back with our experts, the high priestess of hauntings, writer and parapsychologist Evelyn Hollow, and the sultan of scepticism, Dr Kieran O'Keefe, forensic psychologist. Kieran, we heard a lot last episode about the Bull family, how they'd built Bawley Rectory. We then saw the new rector, Reverend Eric Smith, and Mabel, his wife, coming into this place. But we finished part one.

162.655 - 171.694 Danny Robbins

with new characters, the Reverend Lionel Foyster and Marianne, taking over this place. They're going to be really significant characters for us this episode.

171.854 - 198.015 Dr Ciaran O'Keeffe

They're a really interesting couple. Lionel had spent some time as a missionary in Canada and he wanted to return to his home country with his wife, Marianne, and also adopted daughter, Adelaide. And what's interesting, there's a huge age gap between them both, even to the extent where Lionel even baptized his future wife as a baby. Oh, my goodness. Is that even allowed? That sounds pretty dodgy.

198.075 - 219.681 Dr Ciaran O'Keeffe

It does sound really weird. But Marianne was an incredibly glamorous woman. She was young. She wore lipstick, which was kind of frowned upon at that time, especially married to, you know, a vicar. but also she would beat all of the men at tennis. You know, she was glamorous and yet she was really extrovert and really out there.

Chapter 2: What haunted experiences did the Foysters encounter at Borley Rectory?

223.447 - 232.74 Danny Robbins

We had that really amazing moment at the end of the episode, Evelyn, where Marianne saw what we think might have been Reverend Harry Bull, that figure in the plum-coloured smoking jacket.

0

232.72 - 245.535 Evelyn Hollow

Yeah, it's a really striking moment because this is the first time where we can potentially put a name to one of the figures that are seen haunting the house that we do believe that it is Harry Bull. And they sort of can't escape the shadow of that family, really.

0

245.836 - 256.01 Evelyn Hollow

But it begs the question, if you move into a house that has strong paranormal activity and then you pass away, do you become one of the ghosts in the house? Do you return to the house? It is a really interesting idea, isn't it?

0

256.03 - 258.377 Danny Robbins

That potentially that could happen to generations of people.

0

258.397 - 268.646 Evelyn Hollow

Well, true, but also Harry Bull specifically said that he would come back. He said that if he didn't approve of the rector that took it over, he would come back as a poltergeist and he would pelt them with mothballs.

268.686 - 269.528 Danny Robbins

And what happened, Ciarán?

270.352 - 281.929 Dr Ciaran O'Keeffe

And he did, apparently. Mothballs were thrown, weren't they? Mothballs were thrown, yes. I mean, whether we think it's paranormal or not, it's an incredible coincidence that he said he would do it, and apparently he did.

282.529 - 306.504 Danny Robbins

OK, well, let's embed ourselves back in the rectory with the Reverend Lionel and Marianne. That apparent appearance of the late Harry Bull has been pretty bloody unsettling, but then things become downright dangerous. Late one night, Lionel is in the bathroom when he hears a sudden cry... rushing to the bedroom. He finds Marianne confused and distressed, holding her hand up to her face.

306.784 - 320.502 Danny Robbins

There is a bloody cut under her left eye. She's been seemingly attacked by an invisible assailant. The next morning, she's got a black eye. Events quickly escalate from there. Sharp pins are left on chairs.

Chapter 3: How did Harry Price's investigations impact the Borley Rectory case?

320.862 - 345.373 Danny Robbins

Large objects appear on the floor, designed, it seems, to trip up any unsuspecting victim. A heavy doorknob flies at Marianne's head, piercing her by inches. The activity does seem to be targeted at Marianne, who, in front of their daughter, jokingly blames it on mischievous goblins. But in reality, she is exhausted and her own health is beginning to suffer.

0

345.974 - 372.465 Danny Robbins

One night, the family sit down to eat dinner, but are interrupted every few minutes by a stone or kitchen utensil flying across the room at them. They resolutely try to ignore these objects whizzing around their heads and carry on eating until a knife strikes Lionel's head. This has gone too far now. Marianne suggests a DIY exorcism. And she wants to do it in a way that may seem...

0

372.445 - 398.335 Danny Robbins

rather bizarre, quite frankly, to the rest of us. Using creosote, a chemical mixture derived from tar, often used for preserving wood. But back then, people would sometimes burn it to fumigate a house, using it to smoke out mites. Will it work on the invisible forces in the rectory? Well, let's see. Because Lionel and Marianne pour creosote onto hot coals,

0

398.315 - 412.63 Danny Robbins

filling their house with an acrid smoke that wafts through every room. Now, goblins, Lionel says, how do you like this? Wow. Exorcism by creosote.

0

412.65 - 434.295 Dr Ciaran O'Keeffe

Kieran, is this a new one on you? It is new, but then again, with my research into exorcisms, I know people would just grab anything that they think will work. And also creosote feels like an older version of a contemporary approach, which is using sage to kind of cleanse the house. You know, the idea of using creosote to kind of cleanse the house of mites and other things.

434.315 - 448.793 Dr Ciaran O'Keeffe

It's a much less environmentally friendly exorcism. It is environmentally unfriendly, I'll give you that much. But like I said, you know, it's the sort of thing where you can imagine anybody grabbing anything that they think might work because they're just desperate to get rid of whatever's there.

449.033 - 467.177 Danny Robbins

Things really do feel like they're kicking off in a big way here. You've got Marianne receiving that injury to her face, having a doorknob thrown at her. It reminds me of those moments in the first part where we had that glass pane smashing and the vase flying past the Daily Mirror journalist. Do we feel that this is a house where people are potentially in danger?

467.437 - 482.54 Evelyn Hollow

I think you're in danger regardless of whether you think it's paranormal or not, because if it's an outsider doing it, then someone means you harm. They're trying to drive you off the property. If it's inside the house, it's your own partner or your own staff or people that you're friends with, in which case that's horrible and psychologically damaging.

483.181 - 492.355 Evelyn Hollow

Or the other option is that it's somebody doing it to themselves. I mean, are we talking about Marianne gone-girling herself, bashing herself in the skull with something? That's psychotic.

Chapter 4: What violent phenomena escalated during the Foysters' time in the rectory?

1307.814 - 1313.361 Danny Robbins

Or is this really him pushing forward the boundaries of parascience? Because it's an incredible level of scrutiny.

0

1313.381 - 1330.268 Dr Ciaran O'Keeffe

I think it's both. I think by putting the advert in The Times, there's an element of publicity there. He knows that the press will be interested in what he's asking for. So I think that's the publicity part. The other part of it is he doesn't have to say it's for a year. He could say it's for a month or two months.

0

1330.308 - 1353.269 Dr Ciaran O'Keeffe

You know, to have the resident in the house and investigating for an entire year is huge. I always tell ghost hunters, you cannot get a sense of a place by just investigating one night. the phenomena may not turn up that particular night. The longer you are at a location, the greater the chances of you capturing the phenomena. And here we've got the holy grail of ghost investigation.

0

1353.429 - 1355.953 Dr Ciaran O'Keeffe

Put people in that location for an entire year.

0

1355.993 - 1368.85 Danny Robbins

Sadly, most of us, we can't afford to rent a haunted house for a year to investigate it. We'd love to do that. These seances that go on with Harry's investigators, do we believe any of the claims being made here? They seem so fantastical.

1368.83 - 1386 Evelyn Hollow

They are. They're really specific, which is useful because that means we can fact check them against things. You know, they're not really vague. But I think the difficulty is that when people are hosting seances is the two things happening. People really are experiencing what they believe is information, whether that's, you know, psychically isn't what they're seeing in their mind or auditorily.

1386.02 - 1399.182 Evelyn Hollow

They believe that they're hearing things. Some people just describe it as a feeling. They feel like someone's talking to them. They feel like something's coming through. And that could just be human error. People are misinterpreting it. They're looking to stitch bits of information together. The other aspect is that people are at it.

1399.583 - 1407.055 Evelyn Hollow

And this is the difficulty when you have so many people involved in a case is that everybody wants to be right. Everyone wants to say, I solved Borley Rectory.

1411.456 - 1415.522 Danny Robbins

Vaasan Sähkö on ylihyvä vaihtoehto.

Chapter 5: What unconventional exorcism method did Marianne propose?

1617.187 - 1639.457 Danny Robbins

To this day, ghost hunters still visit the tiny village of Pauling. Some claim to hear footsteps around the church. Others have heard the sound of those servants' bells ringing. Some even say they've had pebbles thrown at them, just like Harry Price back in 1929. And one of those investigators, too, have combed that site looking for clues.

0

1640.585 - 1664.82 Dr Ciaran O'Keeffe

Yes, it would be pretty strange for a boy that was inspired by Harry Price not to, in some way, follow in his footsteps. Unfortunately, I couldn't go into Borley Rectory, you know, having been burnt down. But I have been to Borley many times. I've investigated the church itself, but also I have sat on the nun's walk.

0

1665.239 - 1682.717 Dr Ciaran O'Keeffe

On the anniversary of her sighting, in the hope that I would see the nun, I never did, but it was one of the most exciting moments of my life, which says something about my life, that I would be sitting on a nun's walk and just thinking, potentially, this is what Harry Price was doing all of those decades ago.

0

1682.737 - 1692.968 Danny Robbins

Well, I can say, look, I don't want to tell you the silly, but here she is now. Wouldn't it be an amazing thing, though, to actually have an experience down at Bolly? How did it feel being there?

0

1693.91 - 1697.919 Dr Ciaran O'Keeffe

It was thrilling. It was like a boy visiting Disneyland for me.

1698.42 - 1700.244 Danny Robbins

Was it the most haunted house in England?

1702.108 - 1703.792 Dr Ciaran O'Keeffe

No, but I love it anyway.

1705.034 - 1709.083 Danny Robbins

Evelyn, will we ever stop being baffled by Borley? Is this case one that will run and run?

1709.418 - 1726.212 Evelyn Hollow

Yeah, I think so. And what makes it difficult is that because it's burned down, people are sort of just chasing the stories. Or like Kieran says, they can go to the area, they can go to the nun's walk. But that means that we can't investigate it with modern techniques. We can't fill the house with cameras. We can't take environmental readings with the equipment that we do have now.

Comments

There are no comments yet.

Please log in to write the first comment.