Menu
Sign In Search Podcasts Charts People & Topics Add Podcast API Blog Pricing

Chantal Hebert

๐Ÿ‘ค Speaker
372 total appearances

Appearances Over Time

Podcast Appearances

The Bridge with Peter Mansbridge
Good Talk -- Do Canadians Care About Alberta?

which was a way to give not only leverage to a future federal government in the case of another Quebec referendum, in this case, Alberta, but also to send a message to people interested in separation that it was going to be a bit harder to determine the circumstances of the question.

The Bridge with Peter Mansbridge
Good Talk -- Do Canadians Care About Alberta?

The last referendum question, by the way, was a paragraph long.

The Bridge with Peter Mansbridge
Good Talk -- Do Canadians Care About Alberta?

It was all but...

The Bridge with Peter Mansbridge
Good Talk -- Do Canadians Care About Alberta?

It wasn't clear in any way, shape or form.

The Bridge with Peter Mansbridge
Good Talk -- Do Canadians Care About Alberta?

You had to have a Google to see the references in it and Google back to what it actually meant.

The Bridge with Peter Mansbridge
Good Talk -- Do Canadians Care About Alberta?

But since then, the UK has had a referendum in Scotland.

The Bridge with Peter Mansbridge
Good Talk -- Do Canadians Care About Alberta?

And in that case, the Westminster Parliament did approve the question posed to Scottish voters, but it also agreed that if it carried that 50% plus one, there would be negotiations leading to independence for Scotland from Scotland.

The Bridge with Peter Mansbridge
Good Talk -- Do Canadians Care About Alberta?

from the UK.

The Bridge with Peter Mansbridge
Good Talk -- Do Canadians Care About Alberta?

So that precedent kind of forces the federal government to say, well, 50% plus one, it's going to be very hard to argue that what's good enough for a Brexit, what's good enough for Scotland independence would not be good enough for a provincial secession result to be recognized.

The Bridge with Peter Mansbridge
Good Talk -- Do Canadians Care About Alberta?

The Supreme Court has also said that

The Bridge with Peter Mansbridge
Good Talk -- Do Canadians Care About Alberta?

that it is constitutionally possible to leave Canada.

The Bridge with Peter Mansbridge
Good Talk -- Do Canadians Care About Alberta?

There is nothing in the Constitution that says you can't have it, but it is also said that you would be obligated to negotiate in the case of a yes victory.

The Bridge with Peter Mansbridge
Good Talk -- Do Canadians Care About Alberta?

But there is no expectation that it would come to a positive outcome.

The Bridge with Peter Mansbridge
Good Talk -- Do Canadians Care About Alberta?

So you could talk about, you know, yes, you want to separate, let's discuss the terms.

The Bridge with Peter Mansbridge
Good Talk -- Do Canadians Care About Alberta?

Everybody comes to the table, but that doesn't mean that you must arrive at a resolution that leads to separation.

The Bridge with Peter Mansbridge
Good Talk -- Do Canadians Care About Alberta?

But why I'm saying I'm looking at the calendar, I'm thinking if Daniel Smith asked that question for October 19th and Quebec is going to have an election on October 5th,

The Bridge with Peter Mansbridge
Good Talk -- Do Canadians Care About Alberta?

This means that the federal government would be debating the referendum question in Alberta while the Quebec campaign is ongoing and would be discussing thresholds that may be higher than 50% plus one.

The Bridge with Peter Mansbridge
Good Talk -- Do Canadians Care About Alberta?

Let me tell you two things.

The Bridge with Peter Mansbridge
Good Talk -- Do Canadians Care About Alberta?

There is not a provincial party in Quebec, a mainstream one, including the federalist liberals that have backed the Clarity Act in any way, shape or form.

The Bridge with Peter Mansbridge
Good Talk -- Do Canadians Care About Alberta?

or the notion that the Parliament of Canada would determine the question that could one day be asked of Quebecers, or that would prescribe a threshold other than 50% plus one.