Elena

Going on a crime spree.

Larceny.

He's like, it's fine.

And he gets her out, lives with her again.

They rebuilt the farm.

Little did he know, though, that Lizzie was harboring a lot of resentment towards him and had begun plotting revenge against him for some perceived wrongdoing.

I was going to say, for what?

In fact, while Paul seemed convinced that Lizzie had been cured, other family members recalled that her behavior became even more erratic than before.

After Lizzie's arrest... People love to try to fix people.

Oh, yeah.

After Lizzie's arrest, Paul's daughter Mary told reporters, in one moment she would be talking about pieces of fabric in a sewing project, and quite suddenly she should be angry and full of rage, muttering about someone who had wronged her terribly.

Sounds like the President of the United States.

It literally does.

Like that was her.

It very much does.

And Paul became increasingly estranged from his family in the months that followed, seemingly content to retreat further and further into this life that he was creating in his head with Lizzie on the farm.

And one day in September, Paul's son, Paul Jr., became concerned about his father's well-being and paid a visit to the farm.

He was met by Lizzie at the front door.

No thanks.

Lizzie claimed that Paul had purchased some property in Bloomingburg and had gone there to inspect the land and she didn't know when he was going to be back.