Erin Moriarty

As Johnston's suspicions mounted, he convinced his friend, Texas Ranger Matt Cawthon, to look at the case. Cawthon too suspected foul play and became frustrated by the faulty police investigation. What kind of evidence should have been taken in that night?

As Johnston's suspicions mounted, he convinced his friend, Texas Ranger Matt Cawthon, to look at the case. Cawthon too suspected foul play and became frustrated by the faulty police investigation. What kind of evidence should have been taken in that night?

As Johnston's suspicions mounted, he convinced his friend, Texas Ranger Matt Cawthon, to look at the case. Cawthon too suspected foul play and became frustrated by the faulty police investigation. What kind of evidence should have been taken in that night?

How much pressure did you have to put on the Hewitt Police Department to take a new look at this case?

How much pressure did you have to put on the Hewitt Police Department to take a new look at this case?

How much pressure did you have to put on the Hewitt Police Department to take a new look at this case?

In September 2006, the results of Carrie's autopsy, done three months after her body was embalmed and buried, finally came in. And still, no proof of how Carrie died. No remnants of pills were found in Carrie's stomach. But there was evidence of Ambien in her muscle tissue, the same sleeping drug Matt researched on the internet.

In September 2006, the results of Carrie's autopsy, done three months after her body was embalmed and buried, finally came in. And still, no proof of how Carrie died. No remnants of pills were found in Carrie's stomach. But there was evidence of Ambien in her muscle tissue, the same sleeping drug Matt researched on the internet.

In September 2006, the results of Carrie's autopsy, done three months after her body was embalmed and buried, finally came in. And still, no proof of how Carrie died. No remnants of pills were found in Carrie's stomach. But there was evidence of Ambien in her muscle tissue, the same sleeping drug Matt researched on the internet.

Bill Johnston points to the photos taken the night Carrie died, which showed discoloration around Carrie's nose and lips, an indication, he says, she may have been suffocated.

Bill Johnston points to the photos taken the night Carrie died, which showed discoloration around Carrie's nose and lips, an indication, he says, she may have been suffocated.

Bill Johnston points to the photos taken the night Carrie died, which showed discoloration around Carrie's nose and lips, an indication, he says, she may have been suffocated.

There are enough questions that 18 months after Carrie Baker died, the Justice of the Peace declared her death was no longer classified as suicide.

There are enough questions that 18 months after Carrie Baker died, the Justice of the Peace declared her death was no longer classified as suicide.

There are enough questions that 18 months after Carrie Baker died, the Justice of the Peace declared her death was no longer classified as suicide.

The police now had a possible homicide on their hands. On September 21st, 2007, the former pastor was arrested and charged with murder.

The police now had a possible homicide on their hands. On September 21st, 2007, the former pastor was arrested and charged with murder.

The police now had a possible homicide on their hands. On September 21st, 2007, the former pastor was arrested and charged with murder.

Matt posted Bond and returned home to his daughters.

Matt posted Bond and returned home to his daughters.