Greg Costa

I break off the surveillance team, and I go and meet the prosecutor, and then we go to the judge's house.

You're walking into a judge's house Sunday morning.

You know what I mean?

We sat down with him, and I just laid out my case.

And when I laid the plastic on top of the hard copy, he's like, oh, yeah, okay.

I've seen enough.

He picks up the pen and signs the warrant.

But the celebration lasted about 10 seconds, because just as they were heading out the door... I get a phone call, and it's Steve Sheerholt, who was my boss at the time, and he says, they're heading to the airport.

And I'm like, do not let either one of them motherfuckers get on a plane.

from where we were to where she was, was probably a good 40 minute drive.

What had happened was there was a health club right by the airport and they had a membership.

So now we've got my partner, he's inside watching Daryl McCarter, Tanya Hutkins McCarter, Tim Hutkins, her son, Tim's wife, and their baby, who was an infant, and they're swimming.

The plan was we're going to serve the search warrant on Tanya and we're going to take her to the Columbus Police Department.

She's going to be fingerprinted.

Then the fingerprint expert is going to examine the fingerprints and tell us whether or not it's her.

So finally, the guys get back.

They've got the search warrant in hand and everything, so we just wait for her to come out.

And she came walking out with all of her family and everything.

You know, the phrase, your heart is beating out of your chest.

Mine had burst through and was doing laps around that parking lot.