Hannah Rosen

And why? I mean, it seems counterintuitive.

And why? I mean, it seems counterintuitive.

And why? I mean, it seems counterintuitive.

So that was a singular study. Has that held up over time?

So that was a singular study. Has that held up over time?

So that was a singular study. Has that held up over time?

So at this point, there's a large body of research saying the arrival of immigrants, even sudden arrival of immigrants, doesn't have a great effect on the American worker, may even have a positive effect. Now, what about the disappearance of immigrant labor because Trump's promises mass deportations. I'm not sure if you can just flip, you know, the findings of this research.

So at this point, there's a large body of research saying the arrival of immigrants, even sudden arrival of immigrants, doesn't have a great effect on the American worker, may even have a positive effect. Now, what about the disappearance of immigrant labor because Trump's promises mass deportations. I'm not sure if you can just flip, you know, the findings of this research.

So at this point, there's a large body of research saying the arrival of immigrants, even sudden arrival of immigrants, doesn't have a great effect on the American worker, may even have a positive effect. Now, what about the disappearance of immigrant labor because Trump's promises mass deportations. I'm not sure if you can just flip, you know, the findings of this research.

Like, is there a similar natural experiment or study that shows how that might affect workers or the economy?

Like, is there a similar natural experiment or study that shows how that might affect workers or the economy?

Like, is there a similar natural experiment or study that shows how that might affect workers or the economy?

Yeah. So it's – If the research is so consistent, so strong, and makes a lot of sense if you think about it a tiny bit more deeply, why do you think this sentiment persists? Is it just a feeling? Because it persists on both the right and the left. It's not as if the left is fighting back.

Yeah. So it's – If the research is so consistent, so strong, and makes a lot of sense if you think about it a tiny bit more deeply, why do you think this sentiment persists? Is it just a feeling? Because it persists on both the right and the left. It's not as if the left is fighting back.

Yeah. So it's – If the research is so consistent, so strong, and makes a lot of sense if you think about it a tiny bit more deeply, why do you think this sentiment persists? Is it just a feeling? Because it persists on both the right and the left. It's not as if the left is fighting back.

They don't necessarily advocate mass deportations, but they are also not fighting back against this idea that immigrants take away American jobs.

They don't necessarily advocate mass deportations, but they are also not fighting back against this idea that immigrants take away American jobs.

They don't necessarily advocate mass deportations, but they are also not fighting back against this idea that immigrants take away American jobs.

Yeah, I had a conversation with Representative Richie Torres of New York right after the election who talked about how a lot of the immigrants in his neighborhood had a surprising amount of anti-untocumented immigrant sentiment. And it made me wonder about... I don't even know how to define this, but sense of chaos, like just a feeling of things not being in control.

Yeah, I had a conversation with Representative Richie Torres of New York right after the election who talked about how a lot of the immigrants in his neighborhood had a surprising amount of anti-untocumented immigrant sentiment. And it made me wonder about... I don't even know how to define this, but sense of chaos, like just a feeling of things not being in control.