Josh Summers
speaker
85 appearances
1 recordings
1 series
first heard Mar 2025
last heard Mar 2025
Josh Summers’s voice in public audio — every appearance, attributed to the second.
Trend
recordings per month · last 12 monthsNo recordings in the last 12 months.Older appearances are listed below; set an alert to hear about the next one.
Appearances
And I would also say another key challenge we faced is we had to be able to eliminate mom or prove to the jury that mom didn't do this, that it had to have been Billy Palaszczuk.
Child abuse cases are inherently circumstantial. And we can never say exactly how that child was struck. We can never say how many times, what type of blunt force instrument was used to cause those injuries. All we're ever really able to say is that this child sustained these blunt force injuries and that these injuries were caused by inflicted or non-accidental trauma.
What we believe happened to Logan was that at some point that morning, after Billy had taken Logan to his mom's, when he was alone with Logan for about 30 minutes or so, for whatever reason, maybe he got upset with the child, maybe he was mad about something else, but for some reason, whatever that may be,
Billy did the worst thing anyone can imagine and inflicted blunt force trauma, struck that child repeatedly again and again and again, and caused all those contusions, fractured a skull, and caused those injuries to Logan's brain, and that the combination of those things obviously led to his death.
Billy must have been angry for some reason, whether at Logan or at something else, took that anger out on Logan, caused those catastrophic injuries in that moment of anger. And then realized what he had done, tried to cover up the crime scene, called Nicole, tried to take Logan to the hospital. But none of those things excuse his intent or what have you to harm this child.
He doesn't get a free pass just because he lost his temper, realized what he had done, and then tried to take the child to the hospital. He's still legally responsible for what he did, for his actions.
So the defense in this case was that Logan had suffered these injuries sometime prior, either through several accidental falls or that his mother, Nicole, had inflicted these injuries.
But it was also important to show that in June, just a month prior to his death, he had been in for a wellness visit. He was a healthy, normal baby, and there were no parental concerns. In other words, there was nothing to indicate that his mother, Nicole, had been neglecting him or abusing him in any way.
In layman's terms, a lucid interval would be where a child suffers catastrophic injuries like the one Logan has, but doesn't present, doesn't become symptomatic until sometime later. And so one of the defensive theories advanced was that these injuries had been inflicted sometime prior to that child being alone with Billy. that he was experiencing a lucid interval.
In other words, he was acting normally and then became symptomatic, presented when he was alone with Billy after Nicole had left the morning that he passed away.
So this is a medical concept. It can happen. But in this case, there was no evidence to indicate that Logan was having a lucid interval, in large part because there was nothing to indicate that Nicole had done anything to hurt this child.
So there were different theories advanced by the defense in this case. One of them that, you know, Logan fell off a counter while his mom was changing his diaper. Another that he hurt himself playing at the swimming pool. But ultimately, there was never really any evidence or testimony to support any of those theories. They were just purely speculation and conjecture.
That's one of the things that I have to do as a prosecutor is that, you know, things may be... stated in front of a jury in opening statement or alluded to in questioning by defense counsel. And then it kind of becomes one of my jobs to eliminate those possibilities.
Nicole and very credibly so denied ever witnessing Logan have any type of fall or accident that would have caused the types of injuries that led to his death. So all of these allegations, it was just conjecture and speculation. There was never anything to support this idea that he had sustained some severe fall from a changing station. or playing at the swimming pool.
There was nothing ever to support that.
Losing a child, any child, but particularly an infant, that is the worst loss that any parent can suffer. And it's something that clearly affected Nicole and clearly stayed with her. You know, one of the things that juries do when we all get caught up in legal semantics and things like that. But ultimately what a jury does is they evaluate people's credibility.
They get to decide whether they believe all, none, or some of what a witness has to say. And I think in this case that Nicole testified very credibly, and I believe the jury believed everything that she had to say.
I think in a case like this, it's so important not to view any one piece of evidence in isolation. But when you look at the totality of the circumstances, when you look at everything together, not just the injuries, but the DNA evidence, the blood evidence,
associated with Logan that was inside of Billy's trailer, when you look at the staged crime scene, the crime scene that had also been tampered with, the burning of trash that happened after law enforcement was called out, when you look at all of these surrounding facts and circumstances, in my mind, it unequivocally established that Billy Palaszczuk murdered Logan Atkins.
The jury found Billy Ploschek guilty of murder.
Showing 61–80 of 85 · page 4 of 5
← Previous
Next →