Narrator/Host

That's the way I was looking at it.

At the time of Holly's disappearance, we knew she was going through a tumultuous time in her life.

As investigators look into Holly's personal life for clues, they learn that about eight months before she went missing, Holly had filed a request for a temporary restraining order against an ex-girlfriend of her husband named Lindsay.

In the filing, Holly alleges that for 18 months, the defendant has continuously posted pictures of herself and my spouse on the internet with comments directed at me and claims I have changed my phone number six times.

Lindsey denied harassing Holly.

In fact, she tells investigators Holly was the one harassing her.

And she was never served with Holly's request for a restraining order.

She was considered a threat.

That's why we wanted to look at her, because we had to consider her.

But when investigators talk to her, she denies having anything to do with Holly's disappearance.

They also discover she had an alibi on the date Holly disappeared.

What did she say?

She provided a full breakdown of her timeline leading up to the disappearance of Holly.

She was not in Fayetteville the night Holly went missing.

So there was no evidence whatsoever to charge her for what happened to Holly.

She had no criminal culpability in this at all.

While Lindsay is fully cleared, investigators say she provides them with some revealing information about John Weimung's activities the night of Holly's disappearance.

She actually told us about a phone call that she had with John, and John said that he was actually on his way to Fayetteville.

When she called him, he was like, I'm on my way.

I can't do this anymore.