Menu
Sign In Search Podcasts Libraries Charts People & Topics Add Podcast API Blog Pricing

Owen Doyle

👤 Speaker
297 total appearances

Appearances Over Time

Podcast Appearances

The Counter Ruck
Is rugby’s TMO process fair?

And the referee then, the maximum he can do normally in all the matches we've seen so far is,

The Counter Ruck
Is rugby’s TMO process fair?

he can send the player for an off-field review to the bunker.

The Counter Ruck
Is rugby’s TMO process fair?

But for some extraordinary reason, Europe aren't using the bunker.

The Counter Ruck
Is rugby’s TMO process fair?

That's confused a lot of people.

The Counter Ruck
Is rugby’s TMO process fair?

I have a lot of texts, come on, why did he just give me a yellow card?

The Counter Ruck
Is rugby’s TMO process fair?

Why didn't he send him for review?

The Counter Ruck
Is rugby’s TMO process fair?

So that's sort of an aside to the main question.

The Counter Ruck
Is rugby’s TMO process fair?

The question of what's been happening in France has been going on for over 20 years, because when I was there on the committee, European committee that appointed match officials and dealt with all these things, there were discussions with the French Federation and the leagues as to why this was happening.

The Counter Ruck
Is rugby’s TMO process fair?

Now, what is happening, in my view, is this, that if the TMO sees it, as I've just said, he will deal with it properly.

The Counter Ruck
Is rugby’s TMO process fair?

And we've seen it 90 times in 100, it's dealt with properly.

The Counter Ruck
Is rugby’s TMO process fair?

If he misses it and he doesn't go to the referee,

The Counter Ruck
Is rugby’s TMO process fair?

Then it is up to the TV director to decide what he replays.

The Counter Ruck
Is rugby’s TMO process fair?

Now, following this, I think it was yesterday or the day before, the French television said, hold on, we are not to blame.

The Counter Ruck
Is rugby’s TMO process fair?

We will put up everything we're asked to put up.

The Counter Ruck
Is rugby’s TMO process fair?

This is down to the TMO.

The Counter Ruck
Is rugby’s TMO process fair?

If he wants something, we will give it to him.

The Counter Ruck
Is rugby’s TMO process fair?

But if TMO has missed it, he's not going to say anything.

The Counter Ruck
Is rugby’s TMO process fair?

So therefore, can we be a little bit suspicious?

The Counter Ruck
Is rugby’s TMO process fair?

that if it's a visiting team, that the French director will do nothing if something is missed.

The Counter Ruck
Is rugby’s TMO process fair?

And if it's the home team, if it's against the home team, will he show it ad nauseum so that the TMO says, oh, I've missed that.